EU: CJEU Advocate General opinion finding Germany’s reinvestment relief for domestic real estate incompatible with EU law
Regime found to be incompatible with free movement of capital because certain nonresident taxpayers not eligible for relief.
The Advocate General (AG) of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on October 15, 2026, delivered an opinion in case C‑410/25 finding that Germany's reinvestment relief regime for domestic real estate was incompatible with EU law because certain nonresident taxpayers were not eligible for the relief.
Under the German rules, capital gains realized on the disposal of certain assets, most notably real estate, may be deferred if the proceeds are reinvested in replacement assets within a period of up to six years. However, the deferral is available only if the original asset formed part of the fixed assets of a German permanent establishment (PE) for an uninterrupted period of at least six years before its disposal. Nonresident companies without a German PE are excluded from the deferral regime and must pay the tax immediately.
The AG concluded that the deferral regime restricts the free movement of capital because it discourages nonresident companies from investing in German real estate or from selling and reinvesting in such assets. The AG also concluded that companies with and without a German PE are objectively comparable because they are subject to the same corporate income tax on gains arising from the sale of German real estate and may equally need the flexibility to reinvest those gains.
The AG noted that the regime remains compatible with EU law in relation to third countries under the “grandfather clause” in Article 64(1) of the TFEU, which provides that member states may continue to apply restrictions on capital movements to or from non-EU countries involving direct investment, including investment in real estate, if those restrictions existed on December 31, 1993.
Read an October 2026 report prepared by KPMG’s EU Tax Centre