EU: CJEU Advocate General opinion confirming validity of 2022 EU solidarity contribution on surplus profits of energy companies
Regulation 2022/1854 validly adopted under Article 122(1) TFEU
The Advocate General (AG) of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on October 22, 2026, delivered opinions in cases C‑153/25 (Italy), C‑358/24 (Belgium), and C‑533/24 (Ireland) proposing that the CJEU confirm the validity of the temporary solidarity contribution introduced by Regulation (EU) 2022/1854 in response to the energy crisis.
The AG found that Regulation 2022/1854 was validly adopted under Article 122(1) TFEU because it addressed an exceptional economic and energy crisis, pursued objectives directly linked to mitigating the consequences of that crisis, was temporary in nature, and reflected the solidarity principle underpinning Article 122.
- Fiscal nature of the temporary solidarity contribution: The AG acknowledged that the temporary solidarity contribution displays fiscal characteristics. However, the AG considered that its principal objective was to address the energy crisis rather than to harmonize direct taxation. The AG therefore concluded that the measure could validly be adopted on the basis of Article 122(1) TFEU and did not require unanimity within the Council.
- Temporary solidarity contribution compatible with legal certainty, legitimate expectations, and non-retroactivity: The AG concluded that neither Regulation 2022/1854 nor the Irish implementing legislation infringes the principles of legal certainty, legitimate expectations, or non-retroactivity. While the Irish legislation had retroactive effect in relation to fiscal year 2022, the AG considered that such retroactivity was justified by the general-interest objective pursued and did not undermine taxpayers’ legitimate expectations, in particular because Regulation 2022/1854 had already been adopted in October 2022 and expressly provided for the application of the contribution to 2022 profits.
- Irish contribution proportionate and compatible with fundamental rights: The AG considered that neither the 75% rate applicable to surplus profits nor the restrictions on the use of historical losses rendered the Irish measure disproportionate or incompatible with the right to property and the freedom to conduct a business. In assessing the burden imposed, the AG emphasized the temporary nature of the contribution and considered the effective rather than merely the nominal tax rate to be relevant. The AG also considered that allowing historical losses to reduce the contribution could undermine the objective of financing measures adopted in response to the energy crisis.
- Member states’ flexibility when implementing equivalent national measures: The AG reasoned that Article 14 of Regulation 2022/1854 allows member states to adopt national measures that differ from the EU solidarity contribution, provided they pursue similar objectives and generate comparable or higher proceeds. The opinion therefore provides important guidance on the discretion available to member states when responding to exceptional economic circumstances (for example, by extending the scope of the contribution to other economic operators).
Read an October 2026 report prepared by KPMG’s EU Tax Centre