EU: Application of anti-abuse rule under parent-subsidiary directive (CJEU judgment)
CJEU decision on the application of the anti-abuse rule under parent-subsidiary directive
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on October 15, 2026, issued its decision in case C-203/25, on the interpretation of the anti-abuse provision in the parent-subsidiary directive (PSD).
Summary
The court confirmed that the PSD anti-abuse provision has a broad scope and is not limited to situations involving conduit companies. The CJEU established that genuine economic activity at the parent level does not automatically rule out abuse, requiring tax authorities to assess the arrangement as a whole across the entire transaction chain. This assessment may extend to transactions outside the distributing subsidiary's member state, and recognition of beneficial ownership under an income tax treaty to address double taxation does not prevent the application of the PSD anti-abuse rule.
Additionally, the CJEU clarified that similar dividend amounts, onward group transfers, and the timing of transfers may indicate a non-genuine arrangement, though abuse cannot be presumed solely based on these factors. The CJEU held that withholding tax exemptions can be denied without proving that the distributing subsidiary itself knew of the abusive arrangement. It is sufficient to demonstrate the subjective element of abuse in relation to at least one participant in the chain of transactions or the ultimate beneficial owner (UBO).
Background
The Advocate General on May 21, 2026, recommended that a withholding tax exemption under the PSD may be denied in exceptional cases (case C-203/25). This denial would apply when a parent company, despite being the beneficial owner and carrying out genuine economic activities, passes dividends to the UBO through an artificial arrangement. An abusive overall plan would exist when the PSD is used to generate income for the UBO that cannot be taxed at the UBO level, such as when dividends are channeled through non-cooperative offshore jurisdictions.
The AG also proposed that abuse of a member state's national tax law does not generally constitute abuse under the PSD. However, PSD abuse would exist when a subsidiary distributes profits to its parent company to evade taxes in the UBO's member state. Read TaxNewsFlash
Read an October 2026 report prepared by KPMG’s EU Tax Centre