EU: CJEU Advocate General opinion on compatibility of Austrian private foundation regime with free movement of capital
AG urged CJEU to hold that free movement of capital does not preclude Austrian rules under which private foundation may deduct distributions to beneficiaries from its corporate tax base only when those beneficiaries are subject to Austrian capital gains tax.
The Advocate General (AG) of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on September 10, 2026, rendered an opinion in case C-475/25 urging the CJEU to hold that the free movement of capital does not preclude Austrian rules under which a private foundation may deduct distributions to beneficiaries from its corporate tax base only when those beneficiaries are subject to Austrian capital gains tax.
Summary
An Austrian private foundation whose beneficiaries were resident in Switzerland derived capital income, including interest income, gains from share disposals, and gains from real estate sales. After making distributions to its Swiss-resident beneficiaries, the foundation sought to reduce its taxable corporate income by the amount of those distributions. The Austrian tax authorities denied the deduction on the grounds that the beneficiaries were not subject to Austrian capital gains tax. The plaintiff challenged the position of the tax authorities and, after several stages of litigation, the case was brought before the Austrian Supreme Administrative Court, which requested a preliminary ruling from the CJEU on whether the regime is compatible with the free movement of capital.
The AG noted that the regime may put foundations with foreign beneficiaries at a disadvantage, discourage cross-border distributions, and make foundations with foreign beneficiaries less attractive, and thus does represent a restriction on the free movement of capital. However, the AG found that the restriction was justified because its purpose was the legitimate objective of subjecting income derived by Austrian private foundations to tax once in Austria, either at the level of the beneficiary through Austrian capital gains tax or, when Austria cannot tax the beneficiary, at the level of the foundation through corporate income tax.
Read an October 2026 report prepared by KPMG’s EU Tax Centre