Global Tax Disputes Update - January 2019
With tax audit and dispute activity rising in almost every country, keeping up with trends and developments is more important than ever. In this edition, you’ll find briefings on key news, events and thought leadership submitted by Global Tax Dispute Resolution & Controversy professionals in KPMG member firms worldwide. Staying informed can be a crucial first line of defense as you manage your disputes around the globe.
Make sure to view our past issues of Global Tax Disputes Update
Insights from around the world
Country-by-country reporting and notification requirements for multinational entity groups have been enacted into tax law in Andorra.
Argentina’s tax administration published guidance on country-by-country reporting and transfer pricing applications.
The September 2018 edition of Asia Transfer Pricing Review features 16 articles about the transfer pricing environment in countries across the Asia Pacific region.
General tax update for financial institutions (October 2018)
The October 2018 edition of this publication summarizes tax developments of interest to financial institutions in the Asia Pacific region from the third quarter of 2018.
China, Japan sign AEO mutual recognition agreement
Japan has become the thirty-sixth country to sign an Authorized Economic Operator mutual recognition agreement with China.
The Full Federal Court confirmed that the deemed source provision in the India- Australia tax treaty can operate to deem income to have a source in Australia for purposes of Australia’s domestic tax law.
ATO final guidance on diverted profits tax
The Australian Taxation Office’s (ATO) final guidance on the Diverted Profits Tax (DTP) clarifies how key elements of the DPT will be interpreted and how the ATO will apply the new measure.
Tax authority guidance on restructures of hybrid mismatch arrangements
The Australian Taxation Office recently finalized its guidance for taxpayers who restructure out of hybrid arrangements. The guidance examines situations where an effort to redress a hybrid arrangement may result in the application of the anti-avoidance principle under Australian tax law.
Tax ruling on certain employee remunerations trusts
Australia’s Commissioner of Taxation released the final version of Taxation Ruling TR/2018/7, covering the Commissioner’s view of how the tax law applies to certain employee remuneration trusts.
Tax implications for cryptocurrencies
The KPMG member firm in Australia highlights current views from the Australian Taxation Office on cryptocurrencies, capital gains tax calculations, chain splits and other tax implications.
Transfer pricing: ATO internal distributor risk guidance, initial impressions
The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) released new guidance outlining its compliance approach to inbound Australian distributors.
The Brazilian Internal Revenue Service (IRS) issued Internal Tax Ruling No 13 on the exclusion of the state value added tax (ICMS) from the basis for calculating program of social integration (PIS) and contribution for the financing of social security (COFINS) taxes.
The ruling states that taxpayers must consider the paid amount of the ICMS after calculating their balance due, and not the amount on their invoices. This position potentially reduces the amount that taxpayers can exclude and/or recover, and it could be challenged in courts.
CARF adopts STJ’s input definition
The Administrative Council of Tax Appeals (CARF) has begun applying Note No. 63 of the National Treasury Attorney General’s Office on claims for PIS and COFINS credits on business inputs.
The note is based on a Superior Court of Justice (STJ) judgment1 in, in which the court granted the right of taxpayers to claim credits on inputs "essential" and "relevant" to their business activities.
Although this position favors taxpayers, uncertainty remains. The STJ also decided that the "essentiality" and "relevance" of the input depend on the analysis of each company’s core business and activities.
New income tax regulation comprises 1,000+ articles
The Brazilian Federal Government published a new Income Tax Regulation2 comprising more than 1,000 articles on taxation, inspection, collection and tax administration.
New administrative procedural measures that generally took effect on 1 January 2019 include amendments relating to administrative appeals for tax and social security purposes.
Costa Rica´s tax administration issued a draft amendment that would modify its guidance relating to entities required to file a country-by-country report.
The Supreme Administrative Court held that the arm’s length principle applies to individuals and intra-state transactions, and to corporate entities and cross-border transactions.
High court interprets tax treaty provisions
The Supreme Administrative Court held that where a tax treaty applies to a taxpayer’s situation, the tax administrator cannot interpret the treaty’s provision using domestic law or regulations. Rather, the tax administrator must apply international law principles and the commentaries to the Model Convention of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.
European Union (EU) finance ministers discussed the European Commission’s recently proposed digital services tax at an informal meeting of the Economic and Financial Affairs Council (ECOFIN) in September 2018.
Updates on EU tax developments, CJEU judgments and their implications for taxpayers
New editions of E-News from KPMG’s European Union (EU) Tax Centre feature updates on EU tax developments that can have both a domestic and a cross-border impact, as well as Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) decisions and other proceedings that could have implications in your country.
- December 7, 2018 edition
- November 26, 2018 edition
- November 9, 2018 edition
- November 2, 2018 edition
- October 16, 2018 edition
- October 1, 2018 edition
- September 17, 2018 edition
Assessing how Brexit could affect supply chains, warehouses
Given the complexity and broad scope of the impact of Brexit across numerous industries and businesses, many boards have questions about how their supply chains and warehouses might be affected.
VAT and the digital economy; certain measures effective 1 January 2019
In recent months, the European Commission has announced detailed proposals aimed at taxing digital services based on revenues generated in the country of consumption.
Code of Conduct report on harmful tax practices, preferential tax regimes, blacklist
The Code of Conduct Group released a report to the Economic and Financial Affairs Council of the EU on the group’s work during the second half of 2018. Member states particularly welcomed the progress achieved on the monitoring of the commitments taken by third countries in the context of the European Union’s blacklist.
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) recently ruled on the compatibility with EU law with the French Supreme Court’s case law in the Accor case.3 The CJEU concluded that this case law is contrary to the fundamental freedoms and that France failed to fulfil its obligations under the EU treaties because the French Supreme Court did not refer the matter to the CJEU.
Withholding tax on dividends from French companies to non-resident loss-making companies (CJEU judgment)
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) ruled that the French withholding tax levied on dividends paid by French companies to non-resident loss-making companies is contrary to the free movement of capital, and thus incompatible with EU law.
Expanded anti-tax fraud procedures and CFC rules
France’s new anti-fraud law4 introduces changes for a range of tax topics – including an updated list of non-cooperative jurisdictions and broadened controlled foreign corporation (CFC) rules.
A claim for deduction of input value added tax (VAT) requires – among other things – an invoice that satisfies certain formal requirements of German VAT law.
Participation exemption regime for dividends originating in third countries is contrary to EU law (CJEU judgment)
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) held that the German participation exemption regime for dividends received from third countries is contrary to the free movement of capital.
A unilateral advance pricing agreement (APA) has been renewed – a first under India’s APA program. The renewal demonstrates the continued interest of taxpayers in the APA program and the government’s commitment to maintain it as a mechanism for resolving transfer pricing disputes.
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) rendered judgment in a case concerning an Irish airline (taxpayer) that had incurred costs – and related value added tax (VAT) – on its attempt to acquire a competing airline.
Israel’s tax authority published guidance that presents its position on the identification and characterization of a business restructuring involving multinational entity (MNE) groups, the associated tax implications, and the specific valuation criteria for the functions, assets and risks of the business in question.
Provisions to transpose the European Union directives on anti-tax avoidance into Italian tax law are pending before the Italian parliament.
Tax rulings, court decision address tax issues in M&As
Recent court cases and guidance from the Italian Revenue Agency offer clarification on tax issues arising in merger and acquisition (M&A) transactions.
The European Commission (EC) found that the non-taxation of certain profits of a US multinational corporation in Luxembourg did not lead to illegal state aid because the treatment was in line with national tax laws and the Luxembourg-US tax treaty.
The Supreme Court of the Netherlands (Hoge Raad) rendered a final judgment in two corporate income tax cases on whether taxpayers, despite being unable to enter into a fiscal unity with subsidiaries established elsewhere in the European Union (EU), are nevertheless eligible for benefits from separate elements of the fiscal unity regime as if a fiscal unity with foreign subsidiaries could be entered into — i.e. the "per element" approach.
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) released a discussion draft on the transfer pricing aspects of financial transactions.
Updated country-by-country reporting guidance, dividends received, employee numbers
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) released new guidance on the implementation of country-by-country reporting pursuant to Action 13 of the base erosion and profit shifting project.
Multilateral instrument ratified by Australia, France, Japan, Slovak Republic
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) announced that the governments of Australia, France, Japan, and the Slovak Republic have deposited their instruments of ratification or acceptance of the multilateral instrument (MLI) under the base erosion and profit shifting project.
Post-BEPS issues concerning cost sharing arrangements in transfer pricing
With the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) updating the rules on cost sharing arrangements through its base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS) project, what changes might organizations need to make in order to remain compliant?
Global mutual agreement procedure statistics for 2017
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development’s (OECD) report on global mutual agreement procedure (MAP) statistics for 2017 covers 85 jurisdictions and "almost all MAP cases worldwide".
Evaluation of OECD’s final guidance, transactional profit split method
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) released final guidance in June 2018 on the application of the transactional profit split method.
Report clarifies effect of MLI on tax treaties
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development released a report that provides an overview of changes to tax treaties resulting from application of the multilateral instrument (MLI).
Peer review of dispute resolution (MAP); BEPS Action 14
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) issued a request for comments and input on a peer review of the tax treaty dispute resolution process under Action 14 of the base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS) project.
New tax law5 in Poland includes mandatory disclosure rules that generally reflect the European Union directive (known as "DAC6") for disclosing cross-border tax planning arrangements.
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) concluded that in a hire-purchase agreement, the supply of a vehicle and supplies of credit can be treated as separate supplies for value added tax (VAT) purposes.
Digital services tax proposal in Autumn Budget 2018
As the uncertainty of Brexit looms, the Chancellor’s Autumn Budget 2018 took decisive action on several significant tax changes, including the introduction of a UK digital services tax, with effect from April 2020.
HMRC updates ‘no deal’ guidance; practical considerations for businesses
HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) publish updated guidance to help businesses plan for a ‘no deal’ exit of the UK from the European Union.
Updated profit fragmentation rules affecting UK business (Finance Bill)
The UK’s rules on profit fragmentation have been updated to remove the additional notification requirements and introduce a new reasonableness test.
Impact of Brexit on business
The fourth Financial Times Brexit and Beyond Summit was held in November 2018, with KPMG in the UK continuing to take part as its founding partner.
UK amends Diverted Profits Tax
The UK’s Diverted Profits Tax (DPT) rules have been amended to:
- Address planning opportunities arising from the interaction of transfer pricing rules and the diverted profits calculation
- Extend the end of the charging notice review period to 15 months after the relevant DPT charge due date (subject to commencement provisions)
- Change the period during which a preliminary DPT notice may be issued6 to 6 months after the last day on which the company tax return can be amended (subject to commencement provisions).
The US Tax Court issued an opinion addressing the interaction of the statute of limitations for an assessment7 under section 6501 with the rules for passive foreign investment company (PFIC) gains.8
SECA tax audits underway as part of IRS compliance campaigns
The Internal Revenue Service’s (IRS) Large Business & International division continues to expand its list of compliance campaigns, with 40 campaigns identified and selected to date. An increase in IRS activity related to the Self-Employment Contributions Act (SECA) tax campaign has been observed.
US Tax Court: CFC’s distribution not qualified dividend income but taxable at ordinary rates
The U.S. Tax Court granted motions for summary judgment for the Internal Revenue Service, finding the taxpayers’ controlled foreign corporation (CFC) in Hong Kong was not a domestic corporation or a qualified foreign corporation. Thus the CFC’s distribution to the taxpayers was not qualified dividend income but was taxable to them at ordinary income tax rates.
Ninth Circuit: Inconsistency between S corporation’s and shareholder’s returns
The US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed in part and reversed and remanded in part a judgment of a federal district court in a taxpayer’s suit for refund of individual income tax.
Second Circuit: Taxable gain from modified variable prepaid forward contracts
The US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit issued a decision that reversed and remanded a case in which the US Tax Court had found for the taxpayer on all issues concerning the treatment of variable prepaid forward contracts that were modified.
Sixth Circuit: Split-dollar life insurance, economic benefit treated as distribution of property to shareholder
The US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit – in a case of first impression – reversed a memorandum opinion of the US Tax Court in which that court concluded that the taxpayers had to treat as income the economic benefits resulting from their S corporation’s payment of a premium on the taxpayer-spouse’s life insurance policy under a compensatory split-dollar arrangement.
Initial impressions: Penalty relief "de minimis error" safe harbor; information returns, payee statements and the proposed regulations
The US Treasury Department and Internal Revenue Service published proposed regulations9 on penalties for failure to file correct information returns or furnish correct payee statements.
Proposed regulations: Modification of discounting rules for insurance companies
The US Treasury Department and Internal Revenue Service released proposed regulations10 that provide guidance on new rules11 for discounting insurance companies’ unpaid losses and estimated salvage recoverable for federal income tax purposes.
Proposed regulations: Foreign tax credit provision under new US tax law
The US Treasury Department and Internal Revenue Service released proposed regulations as guidance under the foreign tax credit provision enacted under the new US tax law.12
US Tax Court: Medical-marijuana dispensary operator deficiency challenge denied
The US Tax Court issued an opinion in a case involving a taxpayer that operated a medical-marijuana dispensary in California.
1 Special Appeal nº 1.221.170.
2 Decree No. 9,580, of 22 November 2018. The publication of this regulation revokes the previous regulation, which was established by Decree No. 3000 and has been in force since 1999.
3 C 310/09.
4 Ref 2018-898, 23 October 2018.
5 Published 23 November 2018 in the journal of laws.
6 Under sections 80 and 81 (Part 3 of FA 2015).
7 Under section 6501.
8 Under section 1291.
11 As enacted by section 13523 of the new U.S. tax law (Pub. L. No. 115-97 enacted December 22, 2017).
12 Pub. L. No. 115-97, enacted December 22, 2017.