In Centrica Overseas Holdings Limited v HMRC [2022] EWCA Civ 1520, the Court of Appeal (CoA) was unanimous in overturning the decision of the Upper Tribunal (UT) which initially held that advisor fees incurred by an intermediate UK holding company (COHL) in the Centrica Plc group were deductible expenses of management under section 1219 CTA 2009. The advisor fees related to a potential disposal of Dutch subsidiary businesses (Oxxio businesses). The CoA held that while the expenses constituted expenses of management, because the expenses were also capital in nature, they could not be deductible due to the capital exclusion in section 1219(3)(a) CTA 2009.
The advisors’ fees comprised:
- £172,423 to PwC, principally for the preparation of a Vendor Due Diligence Report;
- €3,550,515.32 to Deutsche Bank AG London for advice in relation to the disposal of the Oxxio businesses. This included wide-ranging advice and assistance in relation to strategic alternatives for the various businesses; and
- €766,328 to De Brauw Blackstone Westbroek for legal advice on matters of Dutch law.