AG finds PSD may require foreign tax credit to be carried forward where cross-border dividends reduce tax losses
On November 5, 2026, Advocate General (AG) Rimvydas Norkus of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) delivered his opinion in case C-546/25. The case concerns the interaction between the credit method under the Parent-Subsidiary Directive (PSD) and domestic loss carry-forward rules, where dividends received from a subsidiary in another Member State reduce the parent company’s tax losses but no corresponding credit is available for the corporate income tax paid by the subsidiary.
The case concerns two German parent companies which received dividends distributed by a Greek subsidiary. The dividends had been subject to corporate income tax in Greece and were included in the taxable income of the German companies. Since the German companies were loss-making in the relevant years, the dividends did not result in an immediate German corporate income tax liability. However, their inclusion reduced the companies’ losses available for carryforward, which resulted in a higher German tax liability in the subsequent year, when the German parent company turned profitable in 2002. Under the German rules applicable at the time, the Greek corporate income tax could only be credited in the year in which the dividends were received. Consequently, the credit was effectively lost where no German corporate income tax was payable in that year.
The plaintiff challenged the corporate income tax assessments for the years 1997 to 1999 and 2002. In the plaintiff’s view, the German tax authorities infringed EU law by reducing its loss carry-forward through the inclusion of foreign dividends while simultaneously denying a credit for the foreign tax paid. As a result, the plaintiff sought either (i) to offset the Greek corporate income tax paid between 1993 and 2001 against its taxable income for 2002 or (ii), alternatively, to exclude the Greek dividends received in certain years from the tax base altogether.
Following several legal proceedings, the German Federal Fiscal Court asked the CJEU, among other points, whether Article 4(1) of the PSD precludes such treatment and, if so, whether the provision has direct effect1, allowing the parent company to claim a carryforward of the unused foreign tax credit. For more details on the referral, please refer to E-News Issue 225.
The AG recalled that Article 4(1) of the PSD allows Member States to choose between two methods for avoiding the economic double taxation of qualifying distributions. The Member State of the parent company may either exempt the distributed profits from taxation or tax them while allowing the parent company to credit the tax paid by the subsidiary on those profits, up to the amount of the corresponding domestic tax. According to the AG, where a Member State chooses the credit method, the detailed operation of that method must ensure that the relief prescribed by the PSD is effective.
In this respect, the AG noted that although the dividends did not trigger an immediate German tax liability because the parent company was loss-making, they were not tax neutral. By reducing the losses available for carry-forward, the dividends could result in a higher German tax liability in a later profitable year. At the same time, however, the tax paid by the subsidiary could not be credited in that later year and was therefore permanently lost. In the AG’s view, this outcome is incompatible with the PSD. The AG highlighted that, whilst Article 4(1) of the PSD implies a monetary limitation, it does not introduce a temporal limitation. In other words, where a Member State has chosen the credit method for the avoidance of double taxation, the Directive limits the amount of the foreign tax credit (to the corresponding domestic tax) but does not require the credit to be used in the same year in which the dividends are received. Therefore, where the tax effect of the dividends is deferred to a later period (in this case, due to a national loss carryforward provision), the corresponding tax credit must also remain available in that later period.
In reaching this conclusion, the AG referred to the CJEU’s case law concerning the exemption method under the PSD. The AG noted that, in those cases, the Court focused on the practical tax effect of domestic rules and found that PSD relief should not effectively be lost because dividends reduce losses available for carry-forward. In the AG’s view, the same reasoning applies where a Member State has chosen the credit method. Nevertheless, the AG clarified that the PSD does not require the foreign tax to be refunded in the loss-making year or a credit to be granted in excess of the domestic tax attributable to the distributed profits. Rather, the foreign tax credit should remain available where, and to the extent that, the reduction in the loss carry-forward gives rise to a corresponding domestic tax burden in a subsequent period.
The AG also considered that Article 4(1) of the PSD may have direct effect in such circumstances. Once a Member State has opted for the credit method, the obligation to credit the tax paid by the subsidiary, up to the corresponding domestic tax amount, is sufficiently clear, precise and unconditional. Therefore, if domestic law cannot be interpreted consistently with the PSD, the parent company may rely directly on the Directive to claim the credit in a subsequent tax period, to the extent that the dividends ultimately result in a corresponding domestic tax burden through the reduction of carried-forward losses.
In light of the above, the AG proposed that the CJEU find that the German rules at issue are incompatible with the PSD and that, subject to the limits described above, a taxpayer may rely directly on the Directive to claim the foreign tax credit in a later tax period.
Please note that AG Opinions are not binding on the CJEU, and it remains to be seen whether the Court will follow the AG’s proposed interpretation.
AG opinion on the compatibility of final dividend withholding tax with EU freedoms
On November 5, 2026, AG Laulhé Shaelou of the CJEU delivered her opinion in case C-533/25. The case concerns the application of German withholding tax (WHT) to dividends paid to a parent company established outside the EU and, in particular, whether differences in the tax treatment of dividends paid to non-resident and resident companies are compatible with the free movement of capital.
The applicant is a company established in Japan and the sole shareholder of a German limited liability company. The German subsidiary distributed dividends to the Japanese parent and withheld the corresponding amount of tax for the years 2009, 2010 and 2011. Under the Germany-Japan double tax treaty (DTT) applicable at the time, Germany was entitled to levy withholding tax on the dividends at a rate of 15 percent. Until April 1, 2009, that German withholding tax could generally be fully credited against the Japanese corporate income tax payable by the Japanese parent. Following the introduction of a participation exemption into Japanese tax law, however, 95 percent of dividends received from foreign subsidiaries became exempt from Japanese corporate income tax, with only 5 percent remaining taxable. As a consequence, the Japanese parent could effectively no longer credit the German withholding tax against Japanese corporate income tax.
The Japanese parent subsequently applied for a refund of the German withholding tax, arguing that the final taxation of the dividends placed it at a disadvantage compared with German parent companies. For resident parent companies, dividends were also effectively 95 percent exempt from corporate income tax, but withholding tax could be credited against the German corporate income tax liability and, where appropriate, refunded. Following the rejection of its refund claim, the dispute ultimately reached the German Federal Fiscal Court, which referred the case to the CJEU. For more details on the referral, please refer to E-News Issue 216.
The AG started by analyzing the applicable freedom and found that the German rules should be assessed under the free movement of capital rather than the freedom of establishment, since the rules apply irrespective of the size of the shareholder’s participation.
Turning to the substantive treatment of the dividends, the AG concluded that the German rules result in a restriction on the free movement of capital. Dividends paid to a third-country company are subject to final German withholding tax, which cannot be credited or refunded as is the case for resident companies. According to the AG, this less favorable treatment is capable of discouraging companies established in third countries from investing in German companies.
The AG emphasized that third-country and resident companies are in a comparable situation in this context. Under established case-law, when a Member State (either unilaterally or via a convention) chooses to exercise its power of taxation by imposing a charge on dividend income received from a resident company, the situations of resident and non-resident companies become comparable. Because Germany chose to tax these dividends, it created a risk of economic double taxation and was therefore required to ensure that non-resident companies receive the same treatment as resident companies under its national law, regardless of whether they are based in another EU Member State or a third country.
The AG also rejected the argument that the Germany-Japan DTT eliminated the difference in treatment. Although a double tax treaty may remedy a restriction arising under domestic law, the foreign tax credit must fully offset the German tax disadvantage. Following the amendment of Japanese law, the 95 percent exemption applicable to the dividends meant that the Japanese parent company no longer had sufficient Japanese corporate income tax liability to absorb the German WHT credit.
The AG acknowledged that Member States are generally not required to adapt their domestic tax legislation in response to subsequent changes in another country’s tax system. However, she distinguished the present case on the basis that the difference in treatment arose from the German legislation itself. Where Germany relies on the DTT to eliminate that difference, the treaty mechanism must effectively achieve that result. In the AG’s view, compliance with the free movement of capital therefore cannot depend on whether the tax legislation of the relevant third country provides a sufficient tax liability against which the German withholding tax can be credited.
The AG nevertheless considered that the restriction could be permitted under the standstill clause in Article 64(1) TFEU2, provided that the referring court confirms that the relevant restriction has existed continuously since December 31, 1993. If the standstill clause does not apply, the AG considered that the restriction cannot be justified by overriding reasons in public interest, including the need to preserve the balanced allocation of taxing powers or the prevention of a potential double tax advantage.
Finally, the AG took the view that Germany may require a third-country company to provide additional evidence to establish its entitlement to a tax refund, given the tax authorities’ more limited access to information concerning its foreign tax position. However, those requirements must remain proportionate and must not make obtaining the refund impossible or excessively difficult.
In summary, the AG therefore proposed that the CJEU find that the German rules constitute, in principle, a restriction on the free movement of capital under Article 63 TFEU. Nevertheless, that restriction may be permissible under the Article 64(1) TFEU standstill clause if the German Federal Fiscal Court establishes that the relevant restriction has existed continuously since December 31, 1993, and relates to direct investment. If Article 64(1) TFEU does not apply, the restriction cannot, in the AG's view, be justified by the need to preserve the allocation of taxing powers or to prevent the taxpayer from obtaining a double tax advantage. Germany may nevertheless require a third-country claimant to provide appropriate evidence concerning the extent to which German withholding tax could not be credited in its residence state.
Please note that AG Opinions are not binding on the CJEU, and it remains to be seen whether the Court will follow the AG's proposed interpretation.
CJEU dismisses Poland’s action for the annulment of the CBAM Regulation
On November 12, 2026, the CJEU issued its judgment in case C-512/23 concerning Poland’s action for annulment of Regulation 2023/956 establishing the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM Regulation). The Court dismissed Poland’s action and held that the EU legislature was entitled to adopt the CBAM Regulation on the environmental legal basis of Article 192(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), rather than under the special legislative procedure applicable to provisions primarily of a fiscal nature under Article 192(2) TFEU.
The CBAM Regulation seeks to address greenhouse gas emissions embedded in certain goods imported into the European Union and the associated risk of carbon leakage. The Regulation complements the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) by applying equivalent carbon-pricing rules to covered imports. Under the mechanism, authorized CBAM declarants are required to surrender CBAM certificates corresponding to the embedded emissions in imported goods, subject to specified adjustments, including for carbon prices effectively paid in the country of origin. The price of CBAM certificates is linked to the average closing price of EU ETS allowances.
Poland sought annulment of the CBAM Regulation on the basis that the measure should have been adopted under Article 192(2) TFEU, which requires the Council to act unanimously under a special legislative procedure for environmental measures consisting of provisions primarily of a fiscal nature. Poland argued, in particular, that CBAM exhibited the characteristics of a tax and that its budgetary and fiscal objective prevailed over its environmental objective. Poland also argued that CBAM was not a market-based measure because the number of certificates was not capped and CBAM certificates could not be traded.
The Court rejected those arguments. It recalled that the appropriate legal basis for an EU measure must be determined by objective factors, in particular its aim and content, taking account where appropriate of the legislative context. As the special procedure under Article 192(2) TFEU constitutes an exception to the ordinary legislative procedure, the Court held that it must be interpreted strictly.
Examining CBAM's objectives and design, the Court found that its sole objective is environmental protection. In particular, the mechanism is intended both to prevent carbon leakage and to encourage producers in third countries to use more efficient technologies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. According to the CJEU, the generation of CBAM revenue is a consequence rather than an objective of the mechanism. Even if CBAM were regarded as having both an environmental and a budgetary purpose, the environmental purpose would be predominant and any budgetary purpose merely incidental.
The Court also rejected Poland’s argument that CBAM constitutes a tax. In this context, the CJEU highlighted the link between CBAM certificate prices and market-determined EU ETS allowance prices. Consequently, CBAM was considered indirectly market-based. The CJEU noted that, unlike a duty, tax, fee or charge on CO2 consumption, the mechanism does not establish in advance, by applying a predetermined tax base and rate, an amount payable for each ton of CO2 associated with imports.
The CJEU therefore concluded that Article 192(1) TFEU constituted the appropriate legal basis for the CBAM Regulation and dismissed Poland’s action.
On a related note, the CJEU also dismissed on November 12, 2026, six additional actions brought by Poland against various measures of the ‘Fit for 55’ legislative package. For more details, please refer to CJEU’s press release.