error
Subscriptions are not available for this site while you are logged into your current account.
close
Skip to main content

Loading

The page is loading.

Please wait...


      The OECD Forum on Tax Administration (FTA) held its annual Tax Certainty Day on 4 November 2026, bringing together tax authorities, businesses and advisers to discuss how tax certainty can be strengthened across the international tax system, key trends in the newly released 2025 Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP) and Advance Pricing Arrangements (APA) statistics, and to recognise competent authority teams for success in running their MAP and APA programmes.

      Dispute prevention to the fore

      Tax certainty starts well before a dispute reaches the MAP stage. Clear, stable and appropriately simple rules remain important, but so too does the way those rules are administered in practice. Discussions this year focused on how tax authorities and taxpayers can prevent disputes earlier through better risk assessment, cooperative compliance, tax control frameworks, the International Compliance Assurance Programme (ICAP) and APAs, while maintaining effective MAP processes for cases where double taxation does arise. Simplification also remained an important theme, with the OECD emphasising that international tax rules and administrative processes should not themselves create unnecessary complexity or uncertainty.

      Phil Roper

      Partner, Global Transfer Pricing Services

      KPMG in the UK


      Nick Stevart

      Director, Global Transfer Pricing Services

      KPMG in the UK


      APAs remain a cornerstone of transfer pricing dispute prevention

      The 2025 APA statistics demonstrated strong demand for prospective tax certainty, with 1,168 APAs filed (similar to 2024) and 943 granted during the year (12 percent higher than 2024). 84 percent of closed APAs resulted in an APA being granted and the number of rejected applications declined from 56 to 23. 49 jurisdictions reported actively managing cases, unchanged from 2024. The main challenge remains timing: the average APA takes around 40.2 months to conclude, compared with the 30-month target in the OECD's Bilateral APA Manual. As was put rather neatly during the event, there remains a need to "put the A back in APAs". On a positive note, of the jurisdictions which concluded at least 10 APAs in 2025, Denmark, Indonesia, Singapore, Spain and Switzerland all beat the 30 months target so it can be done.

      The statistics continue to show a strong emphasis on APAs in Asia-Pacific jurisdictions. India stands out for the continued expansion of its programme: applications increased to 103 in 2025, from 91 in 2024 and 77 in 2023, while agreements granted rose to 84, from 65 and 32 respectively. Average completion time also fell markedly to 41.5 months, compared with 58.9 months in 2024 and 62.1 months in 2023, pointing to increasing demand alongside more agreements being concluded within shorter timeframes. Japan remains one of the world's most active and successful APA programmes, while Thailand recorded a 200 percent increase in APAs granted in 2025, representing 14 additional agreements.

      The United States APA program showed impressive resilience given the impact of headcount reductions and a government shutdown in 2025. Despite these challenges, the US competent authority concluded 96 bilateral and multilateral APAs in 2025, along with a further 14 unilateral APAs reported separately by the IRS. US APAs remained in high demand with 155 new bilateral and multilateral applications in 2025 compared with 148 in 2024. The average time taken to agree APAs was 45 months but there are very low failure rates which is a strong indicator of the health of the US APA program. Failure rates are expected to remain low, and the duration of APAs may also improve, as a result of the IRS adopting a more rigorous pre-filing process.

      Elsewhere in the Americas, Canada saw demand for new APAs halve alongside a 12 percent increase in the unsuccessful closure rate. 11 cases accepted into Canada’s APA program were closed for “other reasons”. One of the limitations of the OECD statistics is that they don’t explain the reasons for unsuccessful APAs (e.g. did the Competent Authorities withdraw as their positions were too far apart to reach a deal?). Our recent experience has indicated an increased level of difficulty in completing APA processes with Canada in certain industries and transaction types.

      Back home in Europe, Finland took home the awards for most improved APA programme and best APA caseload management. The 23 bilateral APAs agreed by Finland in 2025 matched the number agreed by China and was close to the UK figure. Switzerland continued to represent the gold standard concluding 83 APAs in 2025 (25 percent of their opening inventory) in an average time of 29 months. Whilst not as prolific as their Swiss counterparts, the Netherlands were also a strong performer concluding 38 APAs (36 percent of their opening inventory) in an average of 38 months.

      The statistics published for the UK were not new, they are the same as those already published by HMRC in March this year (see our earlier article “HMRC transfer pricing yield hits an all time high in FY24-25”). The UK statistics showed average completion time improved from 53 to 44 months, the shortest since 2019, and similar to other key treaty partners with mature APA programs like the US (45), Japan (42), Italy (42) and France (43). Somewhat surprisingly there were only 20 APA applications in 2025, down from 45 in 2024, but we are expecting to see larger numbers of applications when the next set of statistics are published.

      The statistics also show some improvement in the productivity of the German and French APA programs during 2025, with Germany agreeing more APAs than 2024 and in less time, reducing its overall inventory. Germany remains a challenging jurisdiction to agree an APA with for certain types of transactions, business restructurings in particular, and success also depends on the treaty partner.

      MAP statistics indicate positive progression

      The newly released 2025 MAP statistics provided encouragement that the OECD’s ongoing efforts to promote improvements in dispute resolution are working. Competent authorities resolved a record 2,971 MAP cases in 2025, 17.6 percent more than in 2024, while the overall year-end inventory reduced slightly despite growth in new cases.

      Around 66 percent of all MAP cases closed resulted in full agreement between competent authorities, with a further 10 percent of cases resolved through unilateral relief or domestic remedies. Only around 4 percent ended without agreement. For transfer pricing (TP) cases specifically, around 80 percent of cases closed in 2025 provided full relief through bilateral agreement (77.2 percent) or unilateral relief (3.2 percent) and a further 2.7 percent were resolved via domestic remedy.

      MAP resolution times also improved, although TP cases still took around 30.3 months on average, compared with approximately 22.6 months for other MAP cases. Average TP case resolution times improve when looking at post 2015 cases which were resolved at the bilateral stage (26.8 months).

      MAP remains highly concentrated, with the top 10 jurisdictions accounting for around 72 percent of all new MAP cases in 2025, broadly unchanged from 2024. Of the top 10 jurisdictions only France, India, Netherlands and Spain were able to shrink their TP caseload in 2025, with Germany having the largest increase in TP cases.

      The standout movement among the jurisdictions with the largest MAP inventories was France, where the inventory fell by around 180 cases during 2025, comprising reductions of around 95 TP cases and 85 other cases. The reduction came up specifically during Tax Certainty Day, with the French competent authority attributing the improvement to increased resourcing, a more pragmatic and solution-oriented approach to MAP, and greater emphasis on training and engagement with treaty partners. The outcomes also suggest that the reduction reflected substantive resolution of TP disputes: of the 254 post-2015 TP cases closed in 2025, 199 (78 percent) resulted in an agreement fully eliminating double taxation and a further 11 received unilateral relief. Full agreements were concentrated particularly with Italy (74), Germany (33), Spain (27), Switzerland (11) and the UK (10). The progress made by the French competent authority is very welcome, but issues remain in France around field audit practices which can impact MAP access and challenges accessing MAP for taxpayer-initiated adjustments.

      For the UK, the OECD data provide a more recent picture of TP MAP activity, covering the calendar year to 31 December 2025. The UK received 132 new TP MAP cases and closed 104 during the year, resulting in its TP inventory increasing from 301 to 329 cases. Average resolution time increased from 25.8 months in 2024 to 28.6 months in 2025, while around 83 percent of TP cases closed provided full relief through bilateral agreement (71 percent) or unilateral relief (12 percent). The UK was also recognised in the OECD's MAP awards for its cooperation with Jersey on non-TP cases, with the pair achieving the highest agreement score in that category.

      While MAP remains concentrated, its geographic reach is considerably broader than a decade ago: 99 jurisdictions reported MAP activity in 2025, unchanged from 2024 but almost double the 51 jurisdictions reporting activity in 2016. This reinforces the importance of capacity building as newer competent authorities develop the resources, experience and negotiating capability needed to run effective MAP programmes.

      Some jurisdictions are leading by example on MAP; Denmark took home the award for speed, closing over 50 transfer pricing cases in an average of around 12 months and, for the fourth year running, the Netherlands took home the award for large MAP caseload management plus second place in the APA caseload management rankings.

      Stakeholder discussions on tax certainty and the path ahead

      While the MAP statistics remain encouraging, there was also recognition that continued improvements in MAP alone are unlikely to be the complete answer. Demand remains high, and greater emphasis is therefore being placed on preventing unnecessary disputes from entering the MAP pipeline in the first place. One business representative also stressed that, where appropriate, resolving a historic issue through MAP should more often be followed by an APA for future years, helping to prevent the same issue generating further audits and returning to MAP.

      A major part of the discussion looked beyond MAP and APAs. OECD survey findings pointed to a clear shift towards dispute prevention, with around 70 percent of business respondents expecting prevention to become their principal focus going forward. There was particular interest in greater use of tax control frameworks and risk-based approaches, under which strong governance and controls could give tax authorities greater confidence in taxpayers' data and processes and allow audit resources to be concentrated on areas of genuine technical risk.

      ICAP was also discussed as part of this broader toolkit. ICAP cannot provide the same legally binding certainty as an APA, but it can provide coordinated, multilateral risk assessment and practical certainty across a number of jurisdictions. Businesses that have participated highlighted benefits including earlier identification of potential issues, insight into how tax authorities assess risk and the opportunity to develop relationships with several administrations at the same time.

      Tax certainty is also extending into newer areas of international tax. The OECD is developing a taxpayer-initiated coordination mechanism for the global minimum tax, under which competent authorities could consult on specific questions arising from the application of their respective domestic implementing legislation.
      The discussions also highlighted the importance of greater communication between audit teams, competent authorities and policymakers. Where an adjustment has already been resolved through MAP, repeating the same adjustment in subsequent audit cycles creates unnecessary work for both taxpayers and tax authorities. Similarly, recurring MAP disputes may point to an underlying issue with treaty wording, guidance or administrative practice that could be addressed further upstream.

      There was also significant emphasis on what makes MAP and APA programmes work effectively in practice. Adequate resources are important, but so are training, continuity, competent authority independence and a pragmatic, solution-oriented mindset. Competent authorities need to be able to approach cases independently from the underlying audit position and focus on achieving principled outcomes under the relevant treaty. The updates to the OECD’s Manual for Effective Mutual Agreement Procedures provide helpful guidance for jurisdictions on MAP best practices. We explored this in a previous article published by Tax Notes International: “Will New OECD Guidance Make Mutual Agreement Procedures More Effective?”

      Overall, this year's discussions suggested that the debate is moving beyond simply asking how MAP and APAs can be made faster. The broader question is how unnecessary disputes can be prevented from entering the system at all, while ensuring taxpayers have access to effective mechanisms where double taxation nevertheless arises.

      The OECD summed this up by describing tax certainty as a toolkit. No single mechanism will be appropriate in every situation: simplifications and safe harbours, cooperative compliance, ICAP, APAs and MAP each have a role depending on the nature and level of risk. Underpinning all of these is the need for greater trust, transparency and cooperation between businesses and tax administrations.

      For further information please contact:

      Our tax insights

      Something went wrong

      Oops!! Something went wrong, please try again