error
Subscriptions are not available for this site while you are logged into your current account.
close
Skip to main content

Loading

The page is loading.

Please wait...


      Introduction

      Stakeholder engagement has become a prominent feature of tax policymaking in recent years. Budget 2026 continued that trend, announcing a substantial programme of consultations, calls for evidence and further engagement, with the Government again looking to businesses, advisers and representative bodies to help shape tax reform.

      This might appear at odds with the joint letter the Chancellor, First Secretary of State and Attorney General sent to ministers in September 2026 reasserting that there is no general duty of consultation and that formal consultation should be used more selectively. However, the letter draws a distinction between what it describes as habitual box-ticking consultation that does not serve people, business or the Government, with a need for more participatory policymaking – involving a wider range of people to help shape ministers’ and officials’ thinking earlier and more directly – to build back public trust in government.

      Many are sceptical about whether responding to consultations really makes a difference. We believe it does. This article provides some recent examples of where the Government has taken on board stakeholder feedback in tax policymaking and considers future opportunities for taxpayers to have their say.

      Sharon Baynham

      Director, Tax Policy

      KPMG in the UK

      You asked, we listened

      The current fiscal environment means there is limited scope for expensive tax incentives or giveaways to encourage UK investment and economic growth. Instead, to help preserve the UK’s tax competitiveness, the Government is increasingly asking taxpayers to identify low-cost or revenue-neutral measures which they believe will (sometimes collectively) help to improve certainty and/or reduce complexity and the compliance/administrative burden on UK business.

      The first notable example of this from the current Labour Government was the publication of the 2024 Corporate Tax Roadmap. The Roadmap was a direct response to calls from stakeholders for more predictability and stability in the UK corporate tax system following a period of tax policy upheaval, with the 2010 Corporate Tax Roadmap held up as a low-cost measure that improved certainty for investors.

      Similarly, after hearing from business that the lack of an HMRC service offering up front certainty on the tax profile of an investment was a major gap in the UK’s tax competitiveness, HM Treasury launched a consultation on the design of a new Advance Tax Certainty Service (ATCS) in March 2025. The Government took on board many stakeholders’ concerns in the final design of the system, including broadening the taxes in scope, providing the ability for a joint application to be made by multiple entities, and a provision that clearances should bind the Government but not the taxpayer.

      After the first year of the ATCS (July 2027), a special HMRC policy board will review the service with a view to making further refinements. Indeed, feedback from stakeholders that the ATCS expenditure threshold was too high has already been taken on board, with Budget 2026 announcing a reduction in the threshold from £1 billion to £300 million.

      Another recent example of influential stakeholder feedback was to the Tax Support for Entrepreneurship Call for Evidence (CfE) published in November 2025, which led to the Budget 2026 announcement of a new capital gains tax (CGT) ‘Founders’ Relief’, providing a reduced 10 percent CGT rate on up to £10 million of lifetime gains, and strengthening Company Share Option Plans (CSOPs) for businesses that have outgrown the Enterprise Management Incentive (EMI) scheme.

      There are plenty of other recent examples to choose from where stakeholder feedback has translated into government action, including (but not limited to) the Budget 2026 announcements regarding:

      • The abolition of the research and development (R&D) tax Claim Notification Form and simplification of the Additional Information Form;
      • Alignment of the Minimum Platform Threshold for the new online marketplace VAT rules with the VAT registration threshold of £90,000; and
      • The Introduction of an elective credit mechanism for the taxation of reverse hybrids, rather than pursuing the original proposal to treat qualifying reverse hybrids as transparent.

      What’s next?

      There were various new consultations announced at Budget 2026, including in the short term the consultation on the detailed design of Founders’ Relief (closes 30 November 2026) and the direct taxation of foreign sovereign investments (closes 20 January 2027). Of particular note is the Corporate Tax Simplification for Business Investment (CTSBI) consultation, which marks an important milestone in this Government’s stakeholder engagement journey.

      Rather than being focussed on one discrete tax issue, CTSBI is a wide-ranging programme of consultation across multiple areas of the corporate tax regime about which stakeholders have expressed concern, including R&D tax relief, capital allowances, Patent Box, the intangibles regimes and international tax.

      Removing duplication and overlapping regimes for large companies and complex groups is an important part of this discussion, particularly in the post-Pillar Two environment. Whilst the Government has stopped short of proposing wholesale abolition of the Controlled Foreign Company (CFC) or anti-hybrid regimes, it is considering how those rules could be simplified for groups within Pillar Two. It is also seeking views on how the complexity and compliance burden associated with the Corporate Interest Restriction (CIR) might be reduced whilst protecting the UK tax base. In response to ongoing consultation on the transfer pricing International Controlled Transactions Schedule (ICTS), some relaxations to the requirement to file an ICTS will also be considered.

      Importantly, this consultation moves away from traditional written consultation responses to a more dynamic approach. Between November 2026 and April 2027, HM Treasury and HMRC will establish a series of working groups and facilitate roundtables and technical discussions to gather stakeholder feedback on different topics. The Government will then develop more detailed proposals between May and September 2027, and engage in a final round of technical consultation ahead of a future fiscal event.

      In parallel to this, the Modernising Corporation Tax Administration CfE (MCTA), open until 20 January 2027, will gather views on a wide variety of topics (e.g. record-keeping, software and artificial intelligence, information flows and digital services). Similar to the above, removing duplication and overlap is a theme of this CfE and thematic workshops and verbal representations will be a key means of gathering input.

      Adopting a more holistic approach to tax reform discussions, with a focus on verbal representations, will allow for more meaningful, real-time dialogue, and hopefully make it easier for taxpayers to participate in the process on top of their business as usual activities.

      Don’t ask, don’t get

      Some readers will be quick to point out the flaws in the examples above. The 2024 Corporate Tax Roadmap was criticised for not being ambitious or strategic enough; the ATCS remains limited in scope and HMRC have still to prove they can deliver a timely and effective service; and Founders’ Relief is narrowly targeted, complex and arguably does little to address the UK’s scale-up problem.

      Responding to a consultation doesn’t mean that you will get everything you ask for; but these examples demonstrate that where stakeholders can bring practical evidence and workable solutions to the table, the Government will listen. This applies not only to new policy development but, as the CTSBI and MCTA documents demonstrate, the Government is increasingly open to ideas on how to improve the existing tax regime.

      The message is clear: where an opportunity arises to engage on tax policy reform, there is good reason to seize it.

      For further information please contact:

      Our tax insights

      Something went wrong

      Oops!! Something went wrong, please try again