HMRC have updated their interim guidance on mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind. This now gives further practical direction to employers’ preparations for implementation. With less than six months until the first phase begins, employers should use the latest guidance to test their systems readiness — and not simply check whether their payroll software will be updated.
What has changed?
The phased timetable remains: company cars, vans, associated fuel benefits and employer-provided medical benefits come within mandatory payrolling from 6 April 2027. Most other benefits follow from April 2028, while loans and accommodation remain outside mandatory payrolling until a later, yet to be confirmed, date. Importantly, from April 2027, Class 1A National Insurance Contributions must be reported in real time for both mandatorily and voluntarily payrolled benefits.
Employers already payrolling benefits should therefore prepare, as it will not be ‘business as usual’ for current voluntary payrolling arrangements.
The November update adds or expands practical guidance, brings together common scenarios, and provides additional worked examples covering different benefits and pay frequencies. Employers should study these to ensure their preparations map to HMRC’s expectations.
Clarifications on what counts as 'medical' benefits, reasonable estimates of benefit values, treatment of one-off benefits/expenses, and payroll adjustments (both in-year and post year-end) are also welcome additions to the guidance. These updates provide a useful basis for testing whether proposed processes work beyond straightforward, year-round benefits.
Pay particular attention to exceptions
HMRC have strengthened guidance on employees who leave, including commentary on the interaction with terminations, and those with insufficient pay to collect the tax due. Employers should ensure they have processes in place to identify these cases at an early stage and establish how payroll, HR and benefits teams will share information, reconcile amounts and deal with any outstanding liability.
Further clarification also covers the exception process for globally mobile employees, including when an exception starts and ends, and the interaction with modified PAYE arrangements. The option to retain P11D and P11D(b) reporting for these employees may help address practical difficulties. But employers should not assume that every internationally mobile employee is automatically excluded. Eligibility and the required process need to be considered alongside the organisation’s wider expatriate payroll arrangements.
The update also addresses taxable expenses and benefits covered by a PAYE Settlement Agreement (PSA). Employers should review the boundary between payroll reporting and their PSA process, rather than assume every taxable item must move into payroll.
What should employers do now?
The priority is to turn the guidance into an implementation plan. Key actions to consider include:
- Map your benefits and reporting routes - distinguish benefits mandated from April 2027, those retained on P11Ds, voluntarily payrolled benefits and items covered by a PSA;
- Understand your data flows - agree who supplies benefit values and changes, when information reaches payroll and how missing or late information is handled;
- Stress test realistic scenarios - include starters, leavers, changes in benefit values, insufficient pay and internationally mobile employees;
- Determine your Class 1A readiness - confirm software functionality, reconciliation controls and the implications of moving liabilities into real-time reporting; and
- Fine tune your employee communications - HMRC have now provided some suggested comms materials, but these should be tailored to your workforce.
A first-year penalty easement is planned for certain non-deliberate inaccuracies, but this is not a general exemption from compliance: existing late-filing and late-payment penalties still apply.
Employers should use the additional guidance to close process gaps now, while continuing to monitor developments, refine, and test systems and processes as HMRC continue to update the interim material.
How KPMG can help
KPMG’s employment tax specialists work closely with employers across all sectors to ensure their systems, processes, and underlying data are ready for the transition to mandatory real time reporting for benefits in kind and taxable expenses. Please contact the authors, or your usual KPMG contact, to talk through how KPMG can support your organisation with its mandatory payrolling preparations.
For further information please contact: