Fraud cases are not present only in businesses and on a major scale, but it is easy to encounter other varieties of fraud incidents in everyday life across multiple areas. In particular, fraud cases in the tourism sector can be noticed in many daily activities in locations that attract large crowds of tourists. Below is a list of possible types of tourism-related scams one might encounter in Türkiye, regulation steps put in place by the government and related legal framework.
Taxi Scams
Taxi scams are prevalent in many tourist-heavy cities in Türkiye. Drivers may deliberately take longer routes to inflate the fare or claim that the meter is broken and quote an exorbitant flat rate. In some cases, the meters are tampered with to run faster than normal, resulting in higher charges. Additionally, some drivers might claim they don't have change for larger bills, hoping the tourist will forgo the difference.
People Luring Tourists into Expensive Nightclubs and Restaurants
This type of scam involves locals befriending tourists and inviting them to a bar, nightclub, or a restaurant. Once there, the tourists are presented with exorbitantly high bills for drinks, food, or entry fees. If they refuse to pay, they might be intimidated or threatened by the staff or security, creating a hostile situation that pressures them into paying the inflated amount. The scam takes advantage of the tourists' unfamiliarity with local prices and social norms.
Overcharging at Restaurants
Restaurants, especially those located near popular tourist spots, may not display prices, or have different menus for locals and tourists. Tourists may receive inflated bills with hidden charges for items like bread, water, or appetizers that were brought to the table without being ordered. Some establishments might even add a hefty service charge without prior notice, leading to unexpected high bills.
Fake Guides
Unauthorized guides often approach tourists at well-known attractions, offering their services for a fee. These fake guides might provide incorrect or misleading information about the site, focusing more on extracting money than offering a genuine educational experience. They may also rush through the tour or lead tourists to shops where they earn commissions on sales.
Currency Exchange Scams
Some currency exchange offices in tourist areas might offer unfavorable exchange rates or use deceptive practices. Tourists might receive fewer local currency notes than expected due to sleight of hand, or they might be charged hidden fees that significantly reduce the amount of money they will receive. These sorts of scams take advantage of tourists who are unfamiliar with the local currency and exchange rates.
Street Vendors and Fake Goods
Street vendors may aggressively sell counterfeit or substandard goods, claiming they are authentic or valuable. Commonly sold items include fake designer handbags, watches, jewelry, and carpets. These goods are often sold at prices far exceeding their true value, and tourists may realize only later that they have been deceived when the items quickly deteriorate or are found to be worthless.
"Free" Gifts
A friendly local might offer a "free" gift such as a bracelet or flower. Once the tourist accepts, the giver demands payment and can become aggressive if refused. This tactic relies on creating an uncomfortable scene to pressure the tourist into paying. The cost demanded for these items is usually significantly higher than their actual value, turning what seemed like a kind gesture into a costly mistake.
Hotel Scams
Tourists might book a hotel room online, only to find upon arrival that the hotel is overbooked or that the room is significantly below the promised standard. They might then be directed to a lower-quality hotel under the guise of a favor. Alternatively, some hotels might add unexpected charges for amenities, services, or damage that the tourist did not incur, making the final bill much higher than anticipated.
Fake Tours and Excursions
Tourists may book tours or excursions that turn out to be completely different from what was advertised. These fake tours often promise exclusive access, exceptional experiences, or luxury accommodations but deliver subpar services, shortened itineraries, or non-existent trips. Tourists are left with no recourse for refunds, as the operators disappear or deny any wrongdoing.
Preventative Steps Taken by the Turkish Government and Local Organizations
The Turkish government and various organizations take several measures to protect tourists from such scams and ensure their safety and enjoyment. Listed below are some key initiatives and regulations in place
Regulation of Taxis and Private Car Services
- TÜRSAB Registration: The Association of Turkish Travel Agencies (TÜRSAB) regulates private car services, including airport pickups. Only TÜRSAB-registered taxis and private car services are authorized to offer these services, ensuring a higher level of reliability and accountability.
- Official Taxi Stands: Licensed taxis are often required to operate from official taxi stands at airports and major tourist areas, reducing the chance of encountering unlicensed drivers.
Information Desks
There are info desks in tourism hotspots that are operated by the Ministry of Tourism and some municipalities, providing authorized support to the tourists.
Monitoring and Regulation of Businesses
- Inspections: Regular inspections are conducted at restaurants, shops, and other businesses in tourist areas to ensure compliance with pricing regulations and fair trading practices. These inspections are generally performed by the Ministry of Trade.
- Consumer Protection Laws: Businesses found to be engaging in fraudulent activities can face fines, closures, and other penalties under consumer protection laws.
Secure Payment Systems
- Credit Card Protections: Encouraging the use of credit cards for payments as they offer better protection against fraud compared to cash transactions. Many businesses in tourist areas accept major credit cards.
- Verified Exchange Offices: Promoting the use of verified and reputable currency exchange offices, often associated with banks or large financial institutions, to prevent currency exchange scams.
Tourism Police
- Dedicated Units: Tourism police units are deployed in major cities and tourist hotspots. These officers are trained to handle issues specific to tourists, such as scams, theft, and other forms of harassment.
- Multilingual Support: Tourism police often speak multiple languages, making it easier for foreign visitors to report issues and seek assistance.
Licensing for Tour Guides:
Awareness Campaigns
- Information Dissemination: Brochures, posters, and online resources provide tourists with information about common scams and tips for staying safe. These are often available at airports, hotels, and tourist information centers.
- Public Service Announcements: Media campaigns including TV, radio, and social media, raise awareness among both tourists and locals about common scams and how to avoid them.
Hotel Accreditation and Ratings
- Quality Standards: Hotels must meet certain standards and obtain licenses from the Ministry of Culture and Tourism. These standards include safety, hygiene, and service quality.
- Transparent Booking Platforms: Encouraging the use of reputable online booking platforms that offer verified reviews and ratings, ensuring that the tourists book accommodations that meet their expectations.
Related Local Laws and Regulations
- Law No. 2634 regulates the licensing, classification, and operation of tourism facilities including hotels, motels, holiday villages, and private accommodations like Airbnb. The aim with this law is to ensure quality standards and consumer protection.
- Law No. 1774 mandates all accommodation facilities, including private rentals, to register guest information and report it to local security authorities. The law helps prevent fraudulent activities related to identity and illegal stays.
- Law No. 1618 outlines the requirements for establishing and operating travel agencies. The aim with this law is to protect consumers from fraudulent practices by ensuring agencies are licensed and adhere to professional standards.
- Law No. 6326 requires tour guides to be licensed, ensuring that they meet educational and professional standards. The law aims to protect tourists from fraudulent guides who might provide misleading information or engage in fraudulent activities.
- General provisions related to fraud (Articles 157-158) apply to any fraudulent activities, including those in the tourism industry.
- Law No. 6502 protects consumers against fraudulent practices, misleading advertisements, and unfair terms in tourism-related contracts.
- The law addresses fraud related to online transactions, including booking and purchasing of tourism services.
- This regulation sets out the procedures for allocating public land to tourism investments. It aims to support tourism development by providing land for new facilities and attractions.
- This regulation establishes the standards for the certification and classification of tourism facilities, such as hotels and resorts. It therefore ensures high-quality services and facilities to improve the overall tourist experience.
- This regulation outlines the procedures and requirements for inspecting tourism-related businesses and activities, in order to ensure compliance with relevant laws, regulations, and standards. It may cover various aspects such as licensing, safety standards, environmental regulations, and financial compliance.
Government-Level Fraud Scenarios
While fraud in the context of tourism can encompass various aspects, including tax-related offenses, it is essential to understand the specifics of fraud. Generally, abuse of government tax incentives can indeed fall under fraud-related tax laws if it involves deliberate misrepresentation or deception to unlawfully obtain financial benefits. Some scenarios where this might occur include:
- False Claims for Tax Credits or Deductions: Businesses or individuals might fraudulently claim tax credits or deductions intended for tourism-related activities by providing false information about the nature or extent of their operations. For instance, a hotel might exaggerate the number of guests or the revenue generated from tourism to qualify for tax breaks.
- Misrepresentation of Eligibility: Companies might falsely represent themselves as eligible for specific tax incentives designed to promote tourism development, such as grants or subsidies for infrastructure improvements or marketing campaigns. They might misrepresent their business activities or inflate their impact on local tourism to qualify for these benefits
- Fake Documentation: This could involve forging receipts, invoices, or other documentation to support fraudulent claims for tax incentives. For example, a tour operator might create fake receipts for fictitious services to inflate their expenses and claim higher deductions or reimbursements.
- Phantom Investments: In schemes involving government incentives for tourism development, individuals or businesses might create fake investment projects or inflate the value of actual investments in order to qualify for tax breaks or grants. These phantom investments might exist only on paper or involve exaggerated valuations of assets.
- Money Laundering through Tourism Activities: In some cases, tourism-related businesses might be used as fronts for money laundering schemes, where illicit funds are integrated into legitimate economic activities to conceal their criminal origins. Fraudulent claims for tax incentives could be part of these schemes to legitimize the proceeds of crime.
Our Latest Forensic Insights
Follow Us on Linkedin
Connect with us
- Find office locations kpmg.findOfficeLocations
- kpmg.emailUs
- Social media @ KPMG kpmg.socialMedia