Dear Readers,
The New Tax Code significantly updated the horizontal monitoring procedure. The amendments affected the admission criteria, as well as the formats and tools of interaction between taxpayers and the tax authorities. In line with these changes, the Ministry of Finance revised1 the Rules for Conducting the Pilot Project on Horizontal Monitoring. Below we present a brief overview of the key changes.
Data Showcase
The updated horizontal monitoring procedure became more technology-driven. To participate in horizontal monitoring, a taxpayer must maintain a data showcase, an information system through which the tax authorities obtain continuous remote access to the taxpayer’s tax and accounting data.
Internal Tax Control System
The procedure significantly strengthened the role of the internal tax control system. The rules introduced mandatory disclosure elements of the internal control system, which taxpayers place in the data showcase and which the tax authorities assess. Based on the assessment results, the tax authorities may issue recommendations, and failure to implement them may result in termination of the horizontal monitoring agreement.
Eligibility Criteria
Participation in horizontal monitoring remained voluntary; however, the authorities updated the admission requirements:
- value of fixed assets: 650,000 times the MIF (previously 325,000 times the MIF);
- amount of taxes and social payments paid: KZT 5 billion (previously KZT 1 billion);
- the rules removed the headcount criterion (previously not less than 250 employees) and the tax risk management filter;
- the rules established mandatory requirements for the availability of a data showcase and an internal tax control system.
In addition, the regulator introduced a separate category for current and former participants of the Pilot Project. Reduced quantitative thresholds applied to this category; however, taxpayers remained required to maintain automated accounting systems, an internal tax control system, and a data showcase.
At the same time, the tax authorities ceased to recognize the status of a participant of the Astana International Financial Centre (AIFC) or of an organization implementing a priority investment project as a basis for horizontal monitoring. The regime applied exclusively to taxpayers that met the established quantitative, technological, and control requirements.
Advisory Council
Within the framework of horizontal monitoring, the rules established an Advisory Council with representatives of the tax authority and the taxpayer. The Council considered disputes and issued a reasoned decision based on the outcome of its review.
From a procedural perspective, horizontal monitoring relied on recommendations rather than notifications. The review process included discussion stages, preparation of a disagreement protocol, and consideration by the Advisory Council. Disagreement on tax-related matters could lead to a thematic tax audit.