error
Subscriptions are not available for this site while you are logged into your current account.
close
Skip to main content

      Scaling personalised customer experiences with AI

      Artificial Intelligence (AI) is opening up new and profound possibilities for organisations to deeply personalize the customer experience like never before.

      With AI, companies can transform the customer journey and radically rewrite the rules of the game. They can also improve costs to serve, reduce friction and improve customer satisfaction.

      For 14 years, KPMG professionals have been asking consumers about their individual experiences with brands. This year, the KPMG Global Customer Experience Excellence (CEE) 2023-24 report explores what AI will mean to the customer experience. It investigates how companies can use AI to orchestrate journeys across the enterprise to deliver stand-out experiences that will win customers time and time again.

      Yet, today's technology is holding brands back. The 2023-24 CEE report saw a global decline in customer perceptions of their experiences. Only two countries out of the 21 included in this year's study, saw a rise in customer satisfaction. The remainder all witnessed declines, and in some countries, a significant decline. Customer attribute the decline to an overall failure of brands to meet their expectations. Technology was also identified as a contributor.

      Download

      Customer Experience Excellence report 2023-24

      (PDF, 15MB)

      The forces behind rising customer expectations

      Customer expectations are rising. Cost-of-living concerns and customer deflection to low-cost and low-satisfaction channels are diminishing customer perceptions of their experiences.

      Understanding the forces behind today's customer experiences can help companies focus on the strategies that will unlock customer loyalty and deliver growth today and tomorrow.

      Customer experience quality is falling
       

      The availability of advancing technologies offers companies low-cost channels to support customers. Too often these are a poor substitute for human interaction, leaving customers feeling underwhelmed and frustrated.

      Technology is only one part of the answer
       

      Customers today want an emotional connection – they want to feel their brands reflect their personality, their lifestyle and their values. Technology needs to reflect this. When it does not, the customer experience diminishes.

      Economic impact on value and values
       

      Macroeconomics continues to play a part in shaping customer opinions of their experience with companies. For most countries, the cost-of-living crisis weighs heavily on customers' decision making and impacts how they perceive value.


      The Six Pillars of Customer Experience Excellence:

      Even in a world fueled by technology and affected by a cost-of-living crisis, the KPMG Six Pillars of Customer Experience remain the essential dimensions of great customer experiences. They act as design principles, providing guidance on where companies should focus to improve experiences for customers.

      auto_fix_normal

      Personalisation

      Using individual attention to drive an emotional connection

      co_present

      Empathy

      Achieving an understanding of the customer's circumstances to drive deep rapport

      remove_red_eye

      Expectations

      Managing, meeting and exceeding customer expectations

      alarm_add

      Time and Effort

      Minimising customer effort and creating frictionless processes

      construction

      Resolution

      Turning a poor experience into a great one

      window

      Integrity

      Being trustworthy and engendering trust



      Customer experience around the globe

      Click on a country below for more information

      The Australian customer experience

      Consumers in Australia are becoming savvier and demanding more from their brands: more personalised experiences, more value for their dollar and more seamless omnichannel experiences. These higher demands have led many brands to see a drop in their Customer Experience Excellence metrics scores this year versus 2021, when the survey was last conducted in this market.

      Leading the brand rankings this year is Bunnings Warehouse, who climbed from fourth place in 2021. Over the last two years, the home and lifestyle retailer has invested in expanding its digital data capabilities to improve Personalisation for their DIY and commercial customers. They also introduced a new e-commerce platform and in-store technology to reduce the time that staff spend performing tasks, which is better spent servicing customers and improving the shopping experience. These investments led Bunnings to be the market leader for three of the six pillars, including Integrity, Time and Effort, and Resolution.

      The Body Shop has risen back into the Top 10 this year, taking second place and leading the Empathy pillar. A key strategy behind their move up the rankings appears to be the brand's decision to incorporate sustainability into their value chain. In doing so, they embraced the growing number of sustainably conscious consumers and offered them experiential initiatives in-store.

      Long renowned for their in-store customer experience, Mecca who came in third place this year, has shifted its focus to blending content, commerce and customer experience online, while also maintaining their strong in-person retailing presence. Mecca's focus on Personalisation and experience are at the core of their technology and digital investments. They now have a single view of the customer, which they can recognise at any point in their journey to better cater to individual needs and preferences. The brand's willingness to adapt to consumers' new way of shopping with their ecommerce investments has contributed to their becoming a market leader in meeting customer expectations.

      The grocery retail sector performed well on the Time and Effort pillar, landing them in the top industry spot for customer experience. As hybrid and work from home arrangements persist, consumers prefer “single basket visits” over weekly or bi-weekly hauls. To capture this segment, the major retailers have continued to invest in small market stores conveniently located near public transport. The non-grocery retail sector, on the other hand, has been challenged in the second half of 2023, as inflationary pressures have reduced discretionary spending for many consumers.

      “Personalisation continues to be recognised as the number one driver for customer experience in Australia. Customers are looking for brands to not just know them, but understand them. AI is increasingly becoming an ally in a brand's technical transformation; although, we continue to see the importance of a customer centric, and often human, approach to digital transformation. These changes allow brands to establish a new foundation for differentiation via Personalisation and omnichannel experience orchestration.”

      Karen Halligan

      Partner, Customer & Operations Advisory

      KPMG Australia

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Apple
      • Bendigo Bank
      • Bunnings Warehouse
      • Chemist Warehouse
      • Dan Murphy's
      • JB Hi Fi
      • Mecca
      • Specsavers
      • The Body Shop
      • THE ICONIC

      The Austrian customer experience

      Integrity is of high concern for consumers in Austria. They are looking to brands to be open and honest, match prices to the value of goods, and deliver on their promises. Each of which has become ever more critical as the country struggles with rising costs of living and persistent inflation challenges.

      Such transparency was a key contributor for Spusu maintaining its spot as the country's top brand in terms of customer experience. The telecommunications leader, according to survey, spent the past years building on its customer-centric approach by ensuring pricing and fees were clear and contract terms straightforward, creating an honest and hassle-free experience for shoppers.

      Consumers are demanding brands be more transparent around their price increases, while also ensuring they are offsetting higher prices with higher value customer experiences. Fielmann, a leading eyewear retailer, has earned its third place among the brand rankings with their in-house manufacturing and cost-effective products that do not compromising on quality. The company's investments in digital transformation, e-commerce and globalization have also contributed to the company's high scores in the Time and Effort pillar.1

      The straightforward and personalised shopping experiences as exemplified by Fielmann as well as second-place pet store brand, Fressnapf, helped the non-grocery retail sector outperform the others. The grocery retail industry follows in second, impressing customers with swift restocking, a diverse selection of choices and friendly staff, all while maintaining high-quality products.2

      On the lower end of the spectrum, the insurance industry has seen more and more dissatisfied customers since 2022. The survey suggests this result has been the perceived disparities between higher indexed premiums and value for money. Yet, insurance company, Generali, saw the biggest move up the brand rankings in large part to its investments in amping up its personal interactions with customers via its insurance agents, strengthening its client relationships and highlighting the value of its products.

      Value and trust continues to be important factors to consider, especially as the larger retail sector is challenged with sweeping structural changes. The aftermath of the Covid-19 pandemic and the ongoing consequences of the Russian government's war on Ukraine, the number of retail stores in Austria continues to decline. At the same, retail agglomerations are rising, while e-commerce continues to grow – all of which will likely impact retailers in developing strategies to create customer experiences that delight customers online and in store.

      “In an era where inflation is on the verge of becoming ingrained in the mind of customers, leading brands must manage to improve the perception of the value they offer to their customers. Excellent customer experience is all about being valued as a person in an environment where everybody just seems to be after your money.”

      Werner Girth

      Partner

      KPMG in Austria

      1 KPMG in Austria client interview, March 2023
      2 KPMG analysis

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • DM
      • Fielmann
      • Fressnapf
      • Hartlauer
      • HOT
      • Leading global online retailer
      • Nespresso
      • ÖAMTC
      • Spusu
      • Tchibo/Eduscho

      The Czech Republic customer experience

      Consumers in Czech Republic are looking for the simple things: good customer service, quality products and no-hassle shopping. And, they want it in-store and online. As brands battle labor shortages, the impact of higher costs of living in the country, and a slowing export economy, keeping up with the simple things is not always, well, simple.

      Air Bank, the reigning brand in the country for a second year, can attribute its lead to its holistic investments to deliver customer service. The bank has prioritised employee training and has revamped its mobile app with chatbots and AI-powered customer support systems.1 They also introduced new products that directly respond to customer feedback. 2All-in-all, the bank retailer continues to foster its customer-centric culture and ensures each customer is on the receiving end of an exceptional experience.

      Delighting customers is a key strategy for Gran Moravia. The cheese supplier does this with quality ingredients, while also engaging their customers in product development, ensuring they create cheeses that meet the country's esteemed, yet diverse, palates.3 Adding to this, the brand has invested in technologies to make shopping online interactive and convenient, while also streamlining operations to ensure efficient order processing and timely deliveries.4

      Delivering goods is the heart of Zásilkovna's business – a logistic company that has remained the third top brand for a second year in a row. With top marks in Time & Effort, Integrity, Resolution and Empathy, the shipping brand has augmented their customer-centric approach by investing in its online and mobile platforms to increase transparency, while making the full delivery process seamless for its customers.

      Zásilkovna, among others, helped boost the logistics sector into the leading position, just ahead of the non-grocery retail. Yet, the two industries are intricately linked as logistics brands are responding to the increased demands for shipping coming out of the increased investments in building out online shopping capabilities by non-grocery retailers.

      The country's recent economic growth is a key driver behind the success of both the logistics and non-grocery retailers. For now, such growth has also given Čedok a boost, moving 86 positions up this year's rankings. In response to the growing desires to travel, the travel agency

      It is remarkable that on the Czech market we have 4 banks in the Top 10. It shows that in the banking sector, brands are clearly more focused on the customer and their needs than in other sectors. Zásilkovna is a traditional member of the TOP 10. However, this year its competitor PPL also entered the TOP 10. We will see how the situation develops in the next year. La Formaggeria Gran Moravia has already placed in the TOP 10 in the past, so it can be seen that customers continue to rate this brand above average. A wide selection and quality of cheeses together with a selection of wines etc. complementing the main cheese offer and tasting options are characteristic of this brand and customers appreciate it. The travel and leisure sector are finally getting fully out of all post-Covid restrictions. Travel agencies now offer more flights to exotic destinations such as the Maldives and Vietnam, and customers appreciate that. Čedok has really jumped up a lot of positions and we will see if other brands in this sector will follow it in the following years.

      Lukáš Cingr

      Director, Management Consulting - Customer & Digital

      KPMG in Czech Republic

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Air Bank
      • Česká spořitelna
      • Fio banka
      • La Formaggeria Gran Moravia
      • Manufaktura
      • MONETA Money Bank
      • PPL
      • Rohlík.cz
      • Spotify
      • Zásilkovna

      The French customer experience

      Consumers in France expect personalised experiences that cater to their unique needs and preferences. Brands are responding by mastering consumer data insights to deliver hyper-personalised content, products and services. This is deepening loyalty to brands that even rising inflation has yet to deter.

      MAIF is considered France's most loyal company in 2023. Taking the top spot on the CEE rankings, the insurer has been on a five-year journey to improve its customer experience. This has led to the insurance brand scoring particularly well on all pillars, leading with Time and Effort. MAIF has also taken steps to showcase their dedication to policyholders' well-being and satisfaction. For example, the company reimbursed €100 million during the pandemic and offered innovative new on-demand insurance for leisure boating.1

      Chanel and Louis Vuitton take the second and third spots on this year's brand listing. The two luxury brands both made impressive climbs up the list, moving up 8 and 23 spots, respectively.

      Chanel's rise comes from their intentional focus on aligning the quality of their high-end experience with the consumer expectations for exceptional products. KPMG in France has supported Chanel's strategy to grow by adding new point-of-sales and extending its market, yet they have been strictly controlling their speed of growth to ensure they can deliver the exceptional brand experience consumers expect at all touchpoints. For example, the luxury brand has made the unique choice to limit ecommerce to products like fragrance and beauty, whereas high-end products (i.e., fashion, jewelry) are only available through brick-and-mortar stores in limited number.

      Louis Vuitton scored high marks for Time and Effort, and Personalisation. Yet, they led the way in the Integrity pillar, a result of the brand's unwavering commitment to transparency, trustworthiness and ethical business practices – all of which resonate strongly with its discerning customer base.

      In addition to Chanel and Louis Vuitton, six other retail brands made it into the Top 10 of this year's rankings. As a result, the non-grocery retail sector was the leading sector for the second year in a row. Across the sector many brands have invested in their omnichannel journey, creating seamless experiences between digital and brick and mortar touchpoints. Further, the sector has done well in addressing ESG issues with sustainable production, new sales models and supporting the circular economy.

      French department store, Printemps, made the greatest leap on the brand rankings in 2023, seeing significant progress in their scores for the Expectation, Integrity and Personalisation pillars. The brand has introduced stronger customer feedback loops to make more effective data-driven customer experience decisions. In addition, Printemps has demonstrated its commitment to ethical practices and transparency.

      As brands face continuing rising inflation rates, they will want to be sure to create exceptional, deeply personalised experiences for their customers by mastering customer data analytics.

      Once again this year, CEE's French rankings bring us their share of surprises and trend confirmations. The insurer MAIF, well known for its focus on customer experience quality, takes first place in the ranking. Luxury brands confirm their positioning. The French play with paradoxes: inflation leads them to consume differently daily, but they remain attached to strong brands and memorable experiences. Leaders are constantly testing and innovating to master the codes of the new, vocal and demanding generations of customers. Omnichannel is now the norm. Differentiation is achieved through the relevance of the message, the immediacy of interactions, and the quality of the customer experience.

      François-Xavier Leroux

      Partner Customer & Digital

      KPMG in France

      1 https://www.europe1.fr/economie/la-maif-rend-100-millions-deuros-a-ses-assures-il-y-a-une-baisse-considerable-des-accidents-de-la-route-3959465

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Chanel
      • Crèdit Mutuel
      • Cultura
      • Decathlon
      • Hermès
      • Krys
      • Louis Vuitton
      • MAIF
      • Mercure
      • Novotel

      The German customer experience

      Consumers in Germany expect great things from their brands. They want highly personalised in-store experiences. Online shopping should be seamless, flexible and easy. They are also more cost conscious as compounding pressures of high inflation, rising costs of living, and higher prices of food and energy affect about 95 percent of consumers, according to survey data. Altogether, the way customers buy and interact with brands is shifting.

      Fielmann has been able to ride the wave of changing consumer behaviors to remain the top brand in Germany for a fourth consecutive year. According to respondents, the optician has been delighting customers with its new omnichannel services, such as a virtual fitting room, which has led to 37 percent growth in its ecommerce business. The family-owned brand also provides employees with training and education to prepare them to provide top tier, customer-oriented service across the sales journey.

      Following suit is Lego, which came in as this year's number two brand. With several new stores added to its German footprint, the toy maker continues to invest in ways to make for nostalgic, haptic in-store experiences for their customers. This includes expanding its product portfolio by 48 percent to better meet the needs of customers with diverse interests and wallet sizes. Lego has also reinforced its ESG commitments – a growing concern for its customers – by supporting children through its Learn through Play initiative.1

      ESG remains a major challenge for many companies in Germany's non-grocery retail sector. While many are attempting to become more sustainable, for example by offering more sustainable clothing lines, retailers continue to see retailers to be a drain on the environment. Making things trickier, inflation is expected to reduce retail sales in 2023, compared to last year.2 Despite the challenges, the sector topped all the others in terms of customer experience, with 52 of the 77 brands surveyed securing a place in the Top 100.

      While the environment is a key concern, especially as the country continues its energy transition, consumers highly prize their time and effort. It's no surprise, then, Uber had the biggest jump in this year's list, moving up 68 places. After 19 months in Berlin, the company has expanded Uber Eats to more than 60 cities in Germany.3 According to our data, the company has also been making strides to personalize their customer experience, seeing the largest improvement in this pillar. They've done so by expanding their services with wheelchair-accessible and last mile services in its ride-hailing business.

      For the first time since conducting the study more than five years ago, Germany's CEE score has dropped. This development is mainly driven by the performance decline in the Expectations pillar – companies are facing increasing difficulties in meeting their consumers' expectations. In order to differentiate themselves from the strong competition, companies should therefore focus on targeted expectation management.

      Tom Lurtz

      Partner, Consulting, Value Chain Transformation

      KPMG in Germany

      1 https://www.lego.com/cdn/cs/aboutus/assets/blt70ef2efdd8d21dc7/LEGO_Annual_Report2022_Final_WEB.pdf 

      2 https://www.zeit.de/zustimmung?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.zeit.de%2Fwirtschaft%2F2023-07%2Feinzelhandel-umsatz-gesunken-inflation 

      3 https://www.uber.com/de/newsroom/uber-eats-angebot-in-sechs-weiteren-stadten-verfugbar/

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Apple Store
      • doc-morris.de
      • Fielmann
      • Flaconi
      • Hugendubel
      • LEGO
      • Mercedes-Benz
      • Rituals
      • Thalia
      • Zooplus

      Hong Kong customer experience

      Coming Soon.

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      coming soon

      The indonesian customer experience

      Integrity matters to consumers in Indonesia. Trust and transparency in advertising, products and services are key tenets for brands to achieve with their customers. This response may be a result of unfortunate fraudulent practices that are growing across the country, deceiving buyers and cheating honest businesses.

      Each of the top three brands in the customer experience rankings scored high in the Integrity pillar. Adidas and Nike, the first and second place customer experience brands in the country, have gained the public’s trust in delivering durable, high-quality products. Adidas talks openly of its data-backed processes behind its latest shoe innovations. Nike has been building their sustainability credibility with by creating more environmentally friendly product lines.

      The country's leading Integrity brand is Samsung Store, which rounds out the top three brands. Samsung's customers comment on the knowledgeable and supportive in-store staff that help them determine the best choice to buy, while investing to make their popular products and features are durable, long-lasting and high-performing.

      Even with all three of this year's top brands being part of the non-grocery retail, the travel and hotel sector outperformed all the other sectors. The end of pandemic travel restrictions has allowed Indonesian tourism to gradually recover and flourish once again for domestic and international visitors. ESG is increasingly encouraged by the Indonesian government. This has led prominent hotels to adopt ESG practices by implementing energy, water and carbon reduction efforts, as well as providing more sustainable food and beverages.

      In addition to environmental concerns, addressing the social challenges facing the country can improve a brand's standing. This includes persisting economic inequality that contributes discrepancies in better education, healthcare and other vital services. Plus, there remains a 26 percent gap in digital literacy and access, which will require investment in infrastructure.

      Mobile telecommunications operator, XL Axiata, has been investing in various initiatives and innovations to enhance network performance to maintain signal availability and quality coverage across the country, while increasing network capacity. These efforts have enabled XL Axiata to jump 28 places – the most of any brand.

      In the digital era, the rapid dissemination of negative news regarding mis-selling or product issue has the potential to swiftly erode brand equity painstakingly built over years. While it takes time to cultivate trust, a brand's reputation can be jeopardized in an instant. Thus, prioritizing the seamless integration of digital capability and authentic human connection within the sales force becomes paramount, serving as a safeguard against the pitfalls of mis-selling and fortifying the resilience of a brand's integrity in the fast-paced landscape of today's digital world.

      Susanto

      Partner, Head of Clients and Market

      KPMG in Indonesia

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Adidas
      • BCA
      • BNI
      • Garuda Indonesia
      • GOJEK
      • GRAB
      • Nike
      • Oppo Store
      • Samsung Store
      • Telkomsel

      The Italian customer experience

      Consumers in Italy are becoming increasingly environmentally conscious. Coming out of a spate of global events – Covid-19, international conflicts, environmental crises – more consumers are seeing it as their duty to do their part to protect the planet. This is influencing their purchasing decisions and their choice to buy from companies who are demonstrating their environmental commitments.

      Giorgio Armani's commitment to sustainability and ethical practices in its business operations helped boost the company into the third spot of this year’s top brands, sitting behind Amazon and Apple. According to CEE survey results, Armani consistently ranks among the highest values in the Empathy pillar (7.92).

      Empathy extends beyond ESG factors. Facing economic instability and higher inflation rates, consumers are assessing companies in their ability to ensure a fairer distribution of economic benefits. They are also choosing companies that offer competitive pricing – a key reason behind Amazon's jump to the top spot in this year's rankings. Italian consumers also appreciate Amazon's diverse selection of products, quick delivery options and its loyalty program, Amazon Prime, that offers discounts and free shipping.

      Amazon is also making significant investments in generative AI to further elevate the customer experience, while optimizing operational efficiencies and provide more advanced services and solutions. Likewise, the Apple Store is actively exploring opportunities to integrate generative AI, to offer customized experiences and to improve the in-store experience even more. 1

      Fostering digitization and adoption of innovative solutions has also been a factor behind Banco BPM's leap up 67 spots in the ranking. Enabling customers with an omnichannel experience, the bank has integrated digital offerings with various engagement methods to create a cohesive, unified journey be it within a branch or online. 2

      Despite the potential benefits AI brings to the customer experience, many consumers in Italy and across the European continent are wary about AI. As a result, the European Commission has introduced the AI Act, the world's first law to regulate the use of artificial intelligence toprotect users' privacy rights and data security. This seeks to limit the usability of AI solutions, which may pose challenges in the coming years for brands as they find the perfect balance between innovative AI solutions and compliance with regulations.

      Technological evolution has undergone exponential acceleration in recent years, and hyper-Personalisation becomes increasingly tangible with the use of big data, AI solutions and predictive analytics. The customer experience becomes seamless, unique and designed to the basis of the context in which they live, their daily habits and needs. In the near future, digital and human experiences will likely have the ability to handle an empathic approach and blend into an inseparable mix.

      Pasquale Ambrosio

      Partner, Management Consulting, Customer & Growth – Center of Excellence, Fintech Lead

      KPMG in Italy

      1 https://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/amazon-sbarca-nell-intelligenza-artificiale-e-sfida-microsoft-e-google-AEsskKHD?refresh_ce=1 

      2 >https://www.financialinnovation.it/elements/Banking/Opinion-Leader/Digital-Transformation-e-innovazione-nei-modelli-di-servizio-evoluzione-dell-Experience-per-il-Cliente-bancario/

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Amazon
      • Apple Pay
      • Apple Store
      • Chanel
      • Dior
      • Esselunga
      • Fineco Bank
      • Giorgio Armani
      • Nike store
      • PayPal

      The Japanese customer experience

      Consumers in Japan want to be entertained. This comes, in part, as an aftermath of continuous pandemic lockdowns and restrictions. Moreso, it's a result of a long-tradition of Japan's retailers perfecting the customer experience with personalised services and exclusive experiences. Such high standards have empowered consumers to expect great things from the brands worthy of their loyalty.

      Tokyo Disney Resort (TDR) and Universal Studios Japan (USJ) are this year's most-favored brands by consumers. Consumers believe they continue to create exceptional experiences worthy of their rising ticket prices. For TDR, it continues to look for ways to improve its customer experience – before, during and after visits to Tokyo Disneyland, Tokyo Disneysea, or its surrounding Disney hotels and facilities. It attempts to do this by regularly updating attractions, shows and park perks with the goal of pleasing its visitors.

      Improving resolution in the customer experience is something the country's amusement parks, department stores and luxury brands do well. As a good example, luxury brand, Dior, which ranks third among this year's top brands, turns around accidents and inadequacies that occur in the customer experience to create an exceptional experience for customers. However, for many others, resolution continues to be a sticky point for consumers, producing the lowest average scores across The Six Pillars since 2021.

      Many of Japan's brands are finding it difficult to fulfill consumers' expectations. Expectation was the only pillar to have seen a decrease in satisfaction scores compared to the previous year. This downshift comes from brands being unable to consistently deliver against what consumers expect – often in terms of frequent system problems, poor response at support desks, or unilateral changes in service levels customers enjoyed in the past. In addition, customers may have higher expectations for brands because they are equally and continuously comparing customer experiences across industries, including those from brands with leading customer experience, such as GAFAM.

      Moreover, differentiated experiences remain a critical tactic for brands in Japan. This may be difficult to achieve especially for retailers that offer similar business models, products or services. Department stores and convenience stores are a prime example where this happens, which makes it easy for consumers to switch to competitors. Looking ahead, brands may want to focus on strategies that will differentiate their customer experience to keep their fans engaged and coming back for more.

      Even in such a challenging environment, the desire for luxury among wealthy consumers was the impetus behind Isetan's jump into the top 10 of brands. The department store, which rose 54 points in the rankings, has successfully created seamless customer experiences both online and in-store for consumers. They've done so by enhancing their online shopping experiences with real-time advice and guidance from store employees. This has improved the customer experience and significantly increased the retailer's Time and Effort pillar scores. Isetan has also delivered fun, exclusive events in store.

      For Japanese consumers, Personalisation, Integrity and Empathy are linked, to a certain extent, where brands with these high scores in these three pillars results in higher brand loyalties. In these brands, customers often do not expect reasonable price, rather they prefer excellent experiences. These brands offer an exclusive and extraordinary feeling, propose a much-desired lifestyle to consumers, or they are amongst Japan's large specialty store segment (like furniture/homeware retail, book and stationary stores). The focus on in-person experiences, such as accessing physical, personalised products in store, while also offering online touchpoints in the front and back. Currently, there are not many brands in the Japan market that have a clear customer experience strategy. This research shows that customer experience is directly linked to loyalty, so we should recognise the importance of customer experience strategies.

      Hiroaki Ijima

      Partner, Head of Customer Experience Strategy

      KPMG in Japan

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Adidas
      • Apple store
      • Dior
      • Hankyu
      • Isetan
      • mont-bell
      • Nike
      • Tokyo Disney Resort
      • Toyota
      • USJ (Universal Studios Japan)

      The Malaysia customer experience

      Consumers in Malaysia have been forever changed by the pandemic. Online shopping reigns supreme. Mobile payment options and click-and-collect services are also preferred as they make shopping accessible, convenient and budget-friendly. Other pandemic side effects continue to persist: supply chain bottlenecks and consumer good shortages. Inflation is also restricting consumer spending as the demand for basic necessities like rent, services and food remain high.

      Maybank, or Malayan Banking Berhad, was able to pull on many of these consumer levers to move up four places to take over the top brand in 2023. The bank continues to build customer-centric omnichannel capabilities. It released the country's first-ever digital home financing solution, Maybank Home2u, and improved its e-wallet, MAE, offering to make budgeting, spending and managing payments easier than ever.1,2 Maybank also expanded its product portfolio to offer affordable and accessible insurance options to lower-income individuals, while also delivering financial literacy programs and initiatives.3

      Social giving, as well as environmental sustainability, are leading values consumers look for in brands. PETRONAS, energy provider and the second leading brand in the country, launched their 12-week accelerator program that offers tech startups mentoring, workshops and industry access to new markets.4 Whereas, third-place brand, Watsons, is using their ESG commitments to introduce sustainable products and ingredients, while also offering customers easier ways to reuse and recycle their bottles.5

      In addition to their ESG efforts, PETRONAS and Watsons also offer their customers convenient, elevated experiences when shopping. The Setel app at PETRONAS makes paying at the pump almost effortless, while also offering the ability to purchase other car-related services, such as car insurance or parking. On top of that, PETRONAS recently launched the Setel Lite app, which is the lightweight version of the app, offering the same refueling experience while consuming less space and mobile data to cater to users with budget smartphones.6 For Watsons, they continued to build on their offline plus online shopping experiences, offering customers the ability to “click and collect” their purchases through a drive-thru, while also having access to augmented reality technology in store.6

      Like the omnichannel experiences being built by Watsons and Maybank, others in the non-grocery retail sector have also made online shopping accessible to their consumers. This is a key win that boosted the sector ahead of all the rest, especially as 77 percent of Malaysian consumers expect retailers to deliver the same cross-channel flexibility they provided during the pandemic8

      Unifi, Malaysia's telecommunications provider, saw the biggest jump up the brand list, moving 31 spots to 21. The leap appears a result of improvements across all pillars; however, the brand saw the highest increase in Integrity, a result of delivering on their promise to improve their services and cater to its diverse customer base.

      As retailers look ahead, they will want to carefully consider the impacts of the economic downturn on consumer spending, which may become more restricted if wages cannot keep up with increasing inflation rates and high costs for essentials.

      In adapting to the changing landscape and shifting priorities post-pandemic, this year, brands continue to actively harness diverse technological innovations to enhance customer experience. Brands are also exploring the expansion of their ecosystem to push boundaries and deliver heightened value to their customers, all with the overarching goal of driving loyalty.

      Alvin Gan

      Executive Director, Head of Management Consulting

      KPMG in Malaysia

      1 https://www.maybank.com/en/news/2022/03/03.page
      2 https://www.nst.com.my/lifestyle/bots/2023/05/914946/tech-maybank-launches-cross-border-qr-payment-service-malaysians
      3 https://www.thestar.com.my/business/business-news/2023/04/24/maybank-mobilises-rm3437bil-in-sustainable-finance
      4 https://www.nst.com.my/business/2023/02/884368/futuretech-30-expands-asia-pacific
      5 https://www.watsons.com.my/pressReleases

      6 https://www.hmetro.com.my/bisnes/2023/04/958910/setel-lite-mudah-diguna-ringkas
      7 https://www.watsons.com.my/delivery-modes-cces
      8 https://kpmg.com/xx/en/home/insights/2022/05/kpmg-adyen-retail-report.html

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • GrabFood
      • Maybank
      • McDonald's
      • Mr DIY
      • MYDIN
      • Petron
      • Petronas
      • Shell
      • Shopee
      • Watsons

      The Mexico customer experience

      Cracking the code on Personalisation can help unlock customer experience success in Mexico. Yet, for many of the country's companies, from big brands to medium and small companies, this continues to be a long, challenging journey. One that will likely require the strategic use of AI and analytics to really understand their customers – their needs, wants, values and so much more.

      This attention to customers is what has enabled the clinical laboratories sector to take off this year. By understanding customer preferences, the industry saw widespread digitalization that is enabling customers to complete time-consuming processes online, and access their records electronically. Leveraging mHealth technologies, consumers are also enjoying more personalised physical and mental health treatments.

      Marriot, the hotel brand, rose to second place in this year’s brand rankings as a result of its guest-centric efforts over the year. Sandwiched between Nike in the top spot and Adidas in third, the company has been exploring technologies that can better predict guests’ desires so they can proactively present experiences that are more accessible, inclusive and delightful.1

      Brands across the country are looking to create seamless omnichannel experiences. Nike is doing this exceptionally well where customers are leveraging the app to review products before coming into the physical store to try on their favorite selections and going back onto the app to make their purchases.2

      Following in Nike’s footsteps is Berel, part of Mexico’s industrial paint brands. Jumping 64 spots in the country’s brand rankings in 2023, the company has invested in real improvements in POS interactions, ranging from demos to advising customers, while also enhancing its virtual online experience.3

      These are steps in the right direction, yet in Mexico, consumers are feeling the impacts of rising costs of living and inflation. With more than a quarter of consumers in Mexico saying inflation is greatly influencing their purchasing decisions, brands should seek out better ways to manage their operations in order to extend cost efficiencies to their customers.

      Whereas consumers are looking for a good deal, they are also more socially and environmentally conscious than ever, with 45% of consumers saying they are willing to pay more to a company they see are being ethical or giving back to society.

      Improving and maintaining a high performing levels of customer experience is key to providing value to customers. AI can be very relevant to help develop frictionless customer journeys and implement innovative solutions in record time. Technology offers brands the customer insights it needs to offer customers personalised offerings. However, the human factor remains imperative to inject customer experiences with empathy and trust. The combination of both elements can build a closer, lasting, and more profitable relationship with our customers.

      Manuel Hinojosa

      Customer Solutions and CRM Partner

      KPMG in Mexico

      1 https://es-us.finanzas.yahoo.com/noticias/5-razones-aplicar-inteligencia-artificial-152300767.html<
      2 https://webmeridian.net/ecommerce/nikes-customer-loyalty-and-retention-strategy/
      3 https://www.berel.com.mx/quienes-somos

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Adidas
      • Amazon
      • Decathlon
      • Farmacias San Pablo
      • Hilton
      • Holiday Inn
      • Mariott
      • Mercado Libre
      • Nike
      • Spotify

      The Netherlands customer experience

      Quality is worth paying for in The Netherlands. Consumers, despite feeling the financial pinch in rising costs of living, continue to demonstrate that they are willing to pay a little more for quality products. Dutch consumers also continue to buy from brands that offer human-centered experiences across their offline and online platforms.

      Keurslager, a national butcher brand, remains the top brand in The Netherlands – a spot they''ve coveted since being included in the research three years ago. A result that seems surprising as the country becomes more conscious about their meat consumption and its sustainable impact. This consciousness, however, translates into a higher appreciation of a certain quality level of meat, which can be found at Keurslager. Furthermore, what's not surprising, is thatKeurslager remains true to offering highly personalised, truly local in-store experiences, which they enhance by placing stores in the center of small villages and neighborhoods to encourage social interactions among customers. Both the quality, and local and personalised experiences this brand offers, contribute to their top marks in the Integrity pillar.

      Similarly, De echte bakker, which returned to third place in the rankings after rising to second in 2022, has demonstrated its commitment to providing its customers with the finest breads and baked goods. Similar to Keurslager, the bakery consistently delivers a local, friendly and positive in-store experience.

      With Keurslager and De Echte Bakker in the top three, it's no surprise that the grocery retail sector came out on top in this year's rankings – as has been the case since the start of this survey six years ago, with the exception of 2020. The sector's success comes from retailers creating a truly integrated omnichannel experience that leverages the power of human emotions at key points across the customer journey.

      Bol.com does this well. The ecommerce giant, which moved up two spots to second place, received top marks in Personalisation, Expectations and Resolution, and continues to outshine its direct competitor, Amazon. This is a result of Bol.com's ability to weave in Dutch culture into its customer experiences and employee benefits.

      Consumers have a declining trust in governmental organisations, due to a variety of recent issues. As a result, this affects broader corporate organisations, since consumers have a tendency to perceive large corporates in the same way as governmental organisations. Consumers are looking to traditional brands to put their customers first, engaging them through genuine, empathetic and transparent communications.

      KLM has been doing just this. As the airline carrier recovers from the aftermath of the pandemic – where airlines couldn't keep up with high travel demands once restrictions were lifted, it has made strategic investments to improve the customer experience onboard and beyond. This has enabled the airline to rise 76 places – the biggest jump on this year's list.

      Technology remains pivotal in providing the right omnichannel experience, however, equal investments should be made in integrating the human touch into the experience. That, in the end, can really set brands apart and accelerate growth.

      Edgar Molenaars

      Customer & Brand Advisory Leading Partner

      KPMG in The Netherlands

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • bol.com
      • Coolblue
      • De Echte Bakker
      • Keurslager
      • Lush
      • Nespresso Boutique
      • Pearle Opticiens
      • Picnic
      • Rituals
      • Van der Valk Hotels & Restaurants

      The Philippines customer experience

      Coming Soon.

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      coming soon

      The Singapore customer experience

      Consumers in Singapore want pleasant experiences. That is, they want their interactions with brands to leave them feeling happy, personally cared for and on the receiving end of value- added services. Singaporeans are also soaking up the many conveniences that AI brings. At the same time, they prefer customer experiences where they interact with people in real time.

      This ability to balance digitization with human-centered service, is what has kept Apple and Apple Pay as the reigning top two brands in Singapore for a second year in a row. In the first instance, Apple uses technology to swiftly respond to customer issues and book in-store service appointments. Service calls, however, are provided one-on-one by an Apple employee either over the phone or in person at the store. As a result, Apple has once again improved their scores in both Personalisation and Time & Effort.

      Apple Pay stands out in the Time & Effort pillar as well. The e-wallet industry has grown to 70 percent adoption rate in 2023, up from 30 percent before the pandemic.1This has created an increasingly competitive and crowded market. To differentiate their services, Apple Pay continues to innovate new ways to provide customers with value-added services in safe and hassle-free ways.

      Innovation continues to be the heart for Changi Airport. Already consistently ranked the World's Best Airport for 12 years running, among other industry accolades, consumers have now ranked it the country's third top brand in 2023.2 The airport's move up four spots, comes as the airport continues to look for ways to make memorable experiences for customers at the airport and beyond. Onsite, the airport offers a gym and swimming pool, shower facilities, nap rooms, and children's play structures. Non-travel consumers can also use the app and benefit from exclusive privileges and rebates.

      Aligning with the top three ranking brands, Singapore's non-grocery retail sector placed ahead of the rest. Their lead comes as a result of their growing focus on delivering sustainable and eco-friendly products to customers, while continuing to look for ways to reduce their overall carbon footprint. In addition, retailers across the industry have also continued their efforts to make their processes more efficient, improving overall Time & Effort pillar scores.

      Efficiency, especially through the use of technology, is a key driver behind Singapore General Hospital jumping 43 spots up the brand list. For example, the hospital has expanded its use of Robotic Process Automation, which has saved 1,350 hours over a 10-month period.3 However, consumers recognised the hospital for the improvements made to support higher scores in Integrity and Personalisation.

      As brands look ahead, they'll want to continue to seek out ways to please their customers with human-led digital experiences and value-added services, all the while considering the expected impacts of inflation on spending.

      n an increasingly digitalized world, brands need to tame the tension between the growing influence of technology, driven by the emergence of generative AI, and customers' desire for human touch and empathy. The winning brands will be the ones who can embrace technology while maintaining a human connection with their customers.

      Guillaume Sachet

      Head of Customer Practice

      KPMG in Singapore

      1 https://www.mordorintelligence.com/industry-reports/singapore-payments-market
      2 https://skytraxratings.com/singapore-changi-airport-is-named-the-worlds-best-airport-2023
      3 https://www.sgh.com.sg/news/patient-care/more-quality-time-with-patients-thanks-to-bot

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • American Express
      • Apple Pay
      • Apple Store
      • Changi Airport
      • Decathlon
      • POSB
      • Sentosa
      • Shell
      • Singapore Airlines
      • Singapore General Hospital

      The Slovakia customer experience

      Like their increasing expectations for quality of customer service, Slovakia consumers' price sensitivity is growing. Faced with higher inflation rates, shrinking disposable incomes and mounting uncertainty, consumers are increasingly influenced by price in their buying decisions.

      Our survey suggests that the some of the best bookstores are in Slovakia. This year they occupy the top two places in this year's survey. Martinus, the country's top-ranked brand for the six consecutive years, has paired exceptional customer services with lower prices with its used book purchase and resell strategy. The recycling program purchases books back from customers and resells them at a lower price to readers. In addition to its obvious sustainability benefits, the program keeps prices low enough to allow for sales to continue to flow.1

      The book retailer has also invested in enhancing its user interface within their e-book shop with better book filtering, a strong book recommendation system and other improvements that are enabling a truer omnichannel experience for customers.2 A similar effort was made by Fio banka, the third best brand in the country. Coming out of the Czech Republic, the brand has been catching up with bigger national banks by introducing digital services like instant payments and the ability to control finances and investments via an online portal.

      These digital investments come as a result of consumers' rising expectations for seamless, frictionless omnichannel experiences. With even minor problems within a digital experience as a possible point of consumer dissatisfaction, many brands are challenged with keeping up with consumers' digital demands, while also creating balanced in-person experiences customers want.

      Panta Rhei, another national bookstore brand, is doing this well. The retailer already manages the largest network of bookstores in the country.3 Its strong physical presence allows it to use its well-designed in-store experience where customers can spend a pleasant, cozy time in the café. The brand's dedication to delivering a seamless, personalised omnichannel experience, along with efforts across each of the pillars has allowed Panta Rhei to jump back to the second spot in the brand listings, after being ranked 15 in 2022.

      Personalisation is the stand out pillar for the logistics sector, which led the market this year. Surpassing the grocery and non-grocery retail sectors for the first time, the sector’s boost was contributed by three of its brands making their way into the Top 20 brand rankings. Whereas notable progress against the Time and Effort pillar helped Prvá stavebná sporiteľňa (PSS), a building savings bank, see the largest positive move in brand rankings, moving from 121 in 2022 to 62 in 2023.

      In 2023, Slovak businesses faced many challenges amid high inflation, economic growth and geopolitical uncertainties. However, despite these headwinds, 15 percent of brands have improved their customer experience score and demonstrated their resilience by refining pricing strategies to maximize value for their clients. Amid this adversity the Time and Effort pillar proved to be the strongest this year, demonstrating the importance of streamlining processes and maximizing efficiency to meet customer needs. As inflation falls bring with it greater economic confidence, these steps can help Slovak businesses to build resilience and take advantage of what the future may hold.

      Quentin Crossley

      Managing Partner

      KPMG in Slovakia

      1 https://www.martinus.sk/knihovratok
      2 https://www.martinus.sk/pomoc/e-knihy/info
      3 https://www.pantarhei.sk/predajne/

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Booking.com
      • dm drogerie markt
      • Dr.Max
      • Fio banka
      • IKEA
      • Martinus
      • Packeta
      • Panta Rhei
      • Pilulka.sk
      • Teta Drogerie

      The Thailand customer experience

      Consumers in Thailand are quickly becoming digital gurus. Since the pandemic, the digital evolution has revolutionized the way customers live, shop and engage with companies. Adding to this shift and focusing consumers on their perceived value interacting with businesses, has been the rising cost of living in the country where GDP growth has been low and inflation high.

      KASIKORNBANK (KBank) is this year's top brand in Thailand, scoring highest in Time & Effort (8.56) and Personalisation (8.53). KBank's move up from second place in 2022 came from its investment in advancing its mobile app and from expanding its digital ecosystem to include ecommerce, payments and wealth advisory. KBank has also begun to bring in value-added services in segments such as clean-energy transportation, education, public health and tourism.

      Apple, which sits in the number two spot this year, has achieved outstanding scores for Integrity (8.95) and Personalisation (8.62). The brand not only delivers innovative products that seamlessly connect to each other, they offer in-store workshops to train users to make the most of their technology.

      In third place is Siam Commercial Bank (SCB). The bank jumped 26 places over the previous year due to their offering a range of financial services that are delivered in-person and online. SCB also continues to attempt to infuse a human touch in what they do, with the goal of enhancing their services and meeting their customers' changing needs, while also leveraging customer data collected through its mobile app and other technologies.1

      With two of the country's largest banks, SCB and KBank, being in this year's top three brands, it's evidence that the banking sector leads the way for other industries in Thailand. A significant portion of the Thai population has access to financial services this and makes winning new customers challenging forthose in the sector so a tailored and seamless customer experience is key to retaining market share. The country's high digital penetration for financial services – the most in all of ASEAN – drives banks to meeting consumers' digital demands with cutting-edge digital products and services that cater to a wider demographic and deliver a positive experience.

      ESG in banking and across all sectors is also becoming a key criteria consumers consider when choosing brands. This rise in sustainability is leading consumers to favor sustainable products as well as those made and packaged in recycled materials. In addition, the Thai government recently updated its climate targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 30 percent by 2030.2 Altogether, companies will need to take a closer look at their ESG practices across their products as well as their operations. KBank, for example, has installed solar panels on office buildings and is moving to electric company vehicles. 3SCB now offers “green loans” to encourage its retail customers to adopt alternative energy products.4

      We have seen an overall decline in the scores across all CX pillars in 2023 which is driven by a change in customer expectations post pandemic, during which time the acceleration of digital adoption providing a more optimal CX is now becoming the norm. This tells us that the pursuit of excellence in CX will never be over and with this in mind, investments in technology, digital and data capabilities need to be maintained and not just be seen as a one-off initiative. This is evidenced by the results of large domestic banks in this year's survey, who have very much maintained a focus on significant investments across these areas.

      Christopher Saunders

      Partner, Head of Advisory

      KPMG in Thailand

      1 https://www.scb.co.th/en/about-us/news/feb-2023/2023-scb-vision.html
      2 https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/resource/Thailand%20LT-LEDS%20%28Revised%20Version%29_08Nov2022.pdf
      3 https://www.kasikornbank.com/th/career/Pages/possible-story/life-esg-kbank.html
      4 https://www.thairath.co.th/news/sustainable/2712671

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Apple Store
      • Bar B Q Plaza
      • Fuji
      • Grab
      • KASIKORNBANK (KBank)
      • KFC
      • Samsung Thailand
      • SCB
      • Starbucks
      • TrueMoney

      The Türkiye customer experience

      Consumers in Türkiye appreciate luxury products. Even as the country faces higher inflation rates and rapidly escalating tax rates, consumers are using their purchasing power to invest in long-lasting, quality brands that prioritize the customer experience with personalised products, cost effective offerings and a commitment to ESG practices.

      The non-grocery retail has made investments across each of these areas. As a result, the sector ranks at the top of Türkiye's first-ever customer experience rankings with scores above 8 across all six pillars. Several sub-sectors, namely electronics and petrol stations, have emerged leaders within the non-grocery retail space.

      Dyson and Apple rank the top two brands, respectively, in the country. Both are high-end brand that offer time-tested and innovative products that consumers deem worthy of the higher price tag. However, consumer loyalty comes as a result of each company's efforts to invest in the areas most important to their customers. Dyson, for example, offers a customer-centric local e-commerce platform at dyson.com.tr. Moreover, Dyson allows customers to buy their product directly from the manufacturer. Customers can also customize their products with their initials when buying in store. Also, Dyson strategically places their pop-up stores in premium shopping malls, and offers fast, free shipping and an easy return policy to increase customer satisfaction.1

      Notably, Dyson's has demonstrated its ESG commitments to diversify their workforce. At the retail level and behind the scenes across its engineering teams, Dyson has made concerted efforts to better balance its human resources in terms of genders, cultures and backgrounds.

      Integrity has been a key pillar of Apple's success in 2023. Despite inflationary pricing and higher taxes on high-tech products, consumers trust Apple's high-speed and reliable customer services, unbreachable firewalls and data privacy measures. As a result, they are opting for previously owned products, which they are able to customize and purchase in-store as easily as they can online. To make this easier for consumers, Apple has authorized prominent resellers and distributors to sell their products and services, and provide support.

      Opet is a good case in point. The national petrol retailer ranks third in the country's brand rankings and proficiently tapped into the emotions of the Türk consumer, connecting customers with advertisements that resonate with cherished values and sentiments. Something international competitors have been unsuccessful in doing. Opet has also invested in customer-centric programs that have elevated the experience at their petrol stations. As they fill up their cars, they can also access well-maintained and high-tech toilets, well-stocked markets and cheerful station personnel.

      The organizational structure of any institution no longer consists solely of its employees. Every person you see on the street and every customer can become a part of your organization, making strategic decisions and shaping the future together. Each individual is both a requester of the demand and a shaper of the supply. The companies, who can leverage what they see today, will likely be the ones who shape the future for tomorrow.

      Ayşegül Eser

      Director, Strategy & Operations

      KPMG Türkiye

      1 https://www.dyson.com.tr/

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Allianz
      • Apple Store
      • Arçelik
      • Dyson Store
      • İş Bankası
      • Opet
      • Paşabahçe
      • Shell
      • Türk Hava Yolları
      • Vakıfbank

      The UAE customer experience

      Consumers in the United Arab Emirates want to engage with friendly, attentive staff who are willing to support them at key points along the customer journey. Yet, companies are challenged in providing seamless omnichannel experiences as well as the effective digital tools (e.g., chatbots) or skilled customer service staff to effectively address customer inquiries.

      For brands like Emirates, offering comfortable, safe and reliable flights supported by advanced technologies, and friendly staff attentive to every little detail is a key strategy that has kept it the top brand in the UAE for three years running. The airline offers extensive movie selection and quality food on board. Emirates focuses on personalizing the experience for its customers at every touchpoint of the journey, such as observing global holidays and offering premium economy seating.

      Etihad Airways is catching up to Emirates, climbing four places to become the third top brand in the country. Over the past five years, the airline has been committed to enhancing its customer experience, investing in advanced technologies to offer more personalised and seamless services, empowering their employees, and attending to the finer details like crew behavior, food quality and aircraft quality.1

      The airline industry, overall, has made a strong comeback from the pandemic as global travel has increased and the UAE is increasingly becoming a business and travel hub. While the oil industry continues to lead the economy, the country has made substantial investments in various sectors, such as tourism, real estate, retain and technology. This diversified approach has resulted in a 6.6 percent growth of the non- oil sector over the last year, fueled by thriving real estate and tourism industries.2

      Air Arabia, the low-cost airline, has expanded its flight routes, while also putting in place strategic investments to offer in-flight customer service that comes closer to luxury airlines and resolve issues in a timely and friendly manner.3As a result, the airline jumped 36 spots up the brand rankings, achieving the biggest positive move.

      UAE's airlines offer other brands a guide to improving their customer experience. Where companies should favor human-provided, empathetic customer service over emotion-less chatbots and FAQs. They should also look for ways to integrate technologies and processes that cross departments to create more cohesive, seamless experiences for customers. The challenge here, however, will be companies overcoming cultural hierarchy norms that maintain strong siloed ways of working. Companies are also challenged by the shortage of skilled professionals in the key areas like technology, customer-experience design, and data and analytics.

      In this year's study, we witness the UAE's CX landscape flourish through heightened technology investments, unwavering customer service focus, and an expanding array of diverse offerings. A data-driven ethos empowers these advances, underpinning operational efficiency. Yet, amidst this progress, challenges persist, notably in technology maturity, siloed workflows and channel-consistent experiences. Addressing these hurdles with empathy while refining CX measurement will drive the UAE towards an even brighter CX future.

      Goncalo Traquina

      Partner, Head of Customer Advisory

      KPMG in the United Arab Emirates

      1 https://www.etihadhub.com/en-ae/news/special-meal-requests
      2 https://www.majidalfuttaim.com/docs/default-source/reports/state-of-the-uae-retail-economy-q4-2022.pdf
      3 https://www.airarabia.com/en/investor-relations

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank
      • Abu Dhabi Islamic Bank
      • Amazon.ae
      • Carrefour
      • Dubai Islamic Bank
      • Emirates
      • Etihad Airways
      • FlyDubai
      • IKEA
      • Vox Cinemas

      The UK customer experience

      In tougher economic times many organisations have struggled to keep customers on-side and are having to work harder than ever to maintain and build great customer experiences. This year overall perceptions of customer experience have dropped to pre-COVID-19 levels, falling 3.8% in the UK in the last year. A combination of rising expectations, concerns over value and, as organisations rely more and more on digital channels, a marked fall in empathy.

      UK consumers want organisations to resolve their problems quickly and with little friction. Knowing this, brands are turning to AI to play ever-bigger roles in their customer and colleague experience. With chatbots, personal assistants and more, organisations are testing AI and other technologies with simple models and algorithms in key processes to better understand how it can fuel their customer experiences.

      However, customers do not want to interact with faceless technology, they want the technology to reflect the brand and personality of the organization they are dealing with, they also want a human in the loop, there when needed.

      The leading organisations in this year's index understand the need for the technology to have human attributes and to be, in effect, a virtual colleague.

      Each of the top three organisations in 2023 are leveraging humanized AI tools effectively. first direct, ranked first in the UK, is striking the right balance between human and machine when anticipating and responding to customer needs, so much so its digital bot “Dot” creates the same high level of satisfaction as its human colleagues.

      Lush, coming in second place, has also introduced an AI chatbot called Marvin to keep pace with the rising volumes in customer experience as the business continues to expand. Marvin, like Dot, is designed with the goal of achieving high levels of customer satisfaction, while at the same time serving as a helpful colleague for members of Lush's contact center.

      Ranked third, American Express has also been operationalizing AI in small, secure use cases, all focused on making their customers' lives simpler and easier. Its generative AI implementation 'Gen X' was believed to be one of the largest AI implementations in a commercial business when it was launched.

      Artificial intelligence is a quintessentially human problem. It's not about technology, use cases and lowering costs, but creating human value, safely and with integrity. So many organisations are embarking on their AI journeys haphazardly – there's never been a more important time to look to the world leaders.

      Tim Knight

      Partner, UK Head of Customer & Operations

      KPMG in the UK

      1 firstdirect.com/press-releases/articles/dot-the-bot-launch
      2 https://www.ultimate.ai/customer-stories/lush
      3 emergingtechbrew.com/stories/

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • American Express
      • Chase
      • Coventry Building Society
      • First direct
      • Hilton Hotels & Resorts
      • John Lewis & Partners
      • Lush
      • Nationwide
      • Specsavers
      • Vision Express

      The US customer experience

      American consumers have great expectations of the brands they do business with – superior service, convenience, sustainable options and lower prices. Feeling the sting of higher prices across industries, shoppers are keen to stretch their budgets. Yet, their aim to make more cost-conscious spending decisions is often challenged by their desire to choose more sustainable goods. Convenience is also prized, but sophisticated shoppers want to ensure the advanced technologies making their lives easier are infused with human interaction points that don't take away from the overall customer experience.

      H-E-B, a grocery retail chain, has been awarded the top brand spot in the US market for delivering excellent customer experiences. A key element of their success has been achieving the highest scores in the Personalisation pillar, which they demonstrated by investing in their communities and bringing local brands into their stores. To further Personalisation while improving efficiencies, the retailer leverages machine learning models to analyze shopper and cart data from their online store to inform decisions around product inventory and pricing, as well as product positions in-store and less obvious product substitutions. All of which creates frictionless interactions in-store and with scheduled pickups from online grocery shopping.1

      The grocery retail sector continues to outperform all other sectors, grabbing top scores across all six pillars. Changes to the grocery market are happening fast, and trends that first emerged during the pandemic are persisting and reshaping the industry. The use of AI and other advanced technologies is a key trend in the industry, which is being used to improve in-store experience and create seamless omnichannel strategies that support customized inventory and lower prices.

      Advanced technologies, like Natural Language Processing (NLP), have been a key contributor to USAA snagging the second spot among top US brands. Using this AI capability, the insurer is able to better categorize customer issues and calls, while pinpointing where human interventions would be most valuable to customers during the auto insurance claims journey or in building summaries for life insurance underwriting.

      As more brands integrate technology into their operations, their challenge will be to create meaningful customer experiences. Humana achieved this in 2023, making the biggest leap up the brand ranking. The health insurance provider moved 119 places by using data inputs to inform and personalize their offering to better meet the needs of their customers.

      As other brands look to improve their scores next year, they will want to find a fine balance between leveraging the power of data with continuous and measurable customer feedback.

      Customers are looking to feel valued after the pandemic. In a tight labor market, the overall experience has declined and prices have risen sharply. Companies seeing profitable growth are delivering technology efficiency with intimate customer empathy and understanding.

      Jeff Mango

      US Customer Experience Practice Lead

      KPMG in the US

      1 https://www.calligo.io/client-success/machine-learning-data-science/heb-stores/

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Barnes & Noble
      • Chick-fil-A
      • Edward Jones
      • Global online retailer
      • H-E-B
      • L.L Bean
      • Navy Federal Credit Union
      • Publix
      • Sherwin-Williams
      • USAA

      The Vietnam customer experience

      Integrity is paramount for consumers in Vietnam this year. As customers tighten their budgets due to rising inflation, they choose to purchase from brands they can trust to deliver on what they promise without taking advantage of those with limited knowledge in specific sectors. Integrity also stretches into personal data protection especially with the exponential growth of data collection and processing.

      Shoe giants, Nike and Adidas rank first and third among the top customer experience brands in Vietnam. Each of these brands performed well in the Integrity, Time & Effort, and Expectations pillars. In the first instance, Nike unveiled its flagship store in Hanoi that emulates a home that includes household items and shoe shelves that one might find within their own living space. 1 Evoking domestic comfort, Nike has attempted to build trust with its customers by localizing its retail experience.

      Adidas, has also focused on localization. Earlier this year, in the spirit of The Year of The Cat, Adidas launched a new collection called “Spring Forward” that was designed to motivate Vietnamese youth to seize opportunities and pursue their goals. The brand is also working to support its community, bringing its global initiative to the country to create safer sports environments for women, with the goal of enabling women to engage in physical activity confidently.2

      Such ethical behaviors that give back to society is highly prized among Vietnamese consumers. A majority (87% based on CEE data) are willing to pay more for products and services offered by eco-friendly and ethically conscious brands. Consumers also embrace the circular economy with a higher tendency to purchase second-hand items more regularly compared to the global average. Ethical shopping practices are particularly pronounced among Vietnamese Gen Z and Millennials, surpassing the levels seen among Baby Boomers.

      Viettel is known by its customers for technologically advanced mobile services. It ranks second among the top brands for customer experience, a result of its use of AI in its network management and monitoring activities. With AI, the brand is able to capture and analyze customer demands and real-time network capabilities, anticipate development trends, proactively identify situations, issue alerts and requests for intervention – all with the goal of reducing customers' time and effort.

      As other brands look to improve their scores next year, they will want to find a fine balance between leveraging the power of data with continuous and measurable customer feedback.

      Consumers ranked the Restaurant and Fast-food industry as the leading sector this year. Two out of five brands from this sector rank among the top 10 brands – a result of significant improvements each brand has made across customer experience pillars. As of November 2022, Highlands Coffee underwent a rebranding to embrace community values. Committed to infusing the essence of the "heart" into their daily operations, the brand has adopted an approach where customers are treated with the same care and respect as one would offer to their loved ones. Through this strategic shift, Highlands Coffee has not only elevated their service quality, but has also fostered a genuine connection with their customers.

      In this era of uncertainty, businesses face both challenges and opportunities. It's crucial for them to adapt to changing dynamics, leverage technology, and prioritize Integrity as well as Expectations. Customers, even with tightening budget, value fulfilling experiences and will invest in brands that embody these qualities, positioning them for success in the future.

      Nguyen Tuan Hong Phuc

      Partner, Head of Customer & Operations Consulting

      KPMG in Vietnam

      1 https://vnexpress.net/nike-ra-mat-khong-gian-mua-sam-the-thao-moi-tai-ha-noi-4614115.html
      2 https://www.globalbrandsmagazine.com/new-adidas-study-finds-92-of-women-are-concerned-for-their-safety-when-they-go-for-a-run/

      Top 10 Companies*

      *listed in alphabetical order

      • Adidas
      • Be
      • Biti's
      • GoFood
      • Highlands Coffee
      • Lock & Lock
      • Nike
      • Trung Nguyen
      • Vietcombank
      • Viettel

      Customer experience from the sector lens

      The banking sector has navigated a sea of changes in recent years – geopolitical shifts, economic uncertainty, advances in technology, energy and climate concerns, the fight for talent and rising customer demands. On top of this, the industry has undergone sweeping transitions.

      Fueled by strong capital and liquidity positions, the industry has shown cautious optimism. Ranked as the second leading sector globally, first direct in the UK, Air Bank in Czech Republic, Kbank in Thailand and Maybank in Malaysia were each named the top brand in their respective countries.

      These and others in the industry are carefully managing risks in the face of such uncertainty, and are prepared to forge forward on the strategies they consider important. This includes progressing against their ESG targets and making the most of emerging technologies.

      The banking sector has long used AI to understand its customers and competitively price its products. Yet, the rise of today's AI, especially common-language generative AI (gen AI), is getting banks to test what is possible with new use cases across operations.

      Already, AI has been helping banks respond to post-pandemic surges in digital interactions and transactions. The technology is also helping create more nuanced individual customer profiles, so banks can create and introduce tailored products and services at the right time.

      Winning clients for life

      Customers' time and effort is a key focus for banks. They want to give customers frictionless, multi-channel experiences where customers can seamlessly interact across various platforms – be they through machines or with humans, and delivered in person or virtually. They also want to transition how they serve customers. Instead of focusing on short-term product sales, the goal is to win the 'client for life' – a concept that is gaining ground across the industry.

      In this model, banks deliver a personalised portfolio of products and services that support customers through specific life events. To further enhance this approach, banks are moving toward an alliance ecosystem. Here, banking products and services will integrate with offerings from various complementary sectors – auto insurance contacts for those seeking car financing or home builder contacts for mortgage customers – to create a comprehensive customer experience.

      AI will likely be instrumental in this shift. Going beyond understanding customer behavior, AI can enhance and personalize the entire customer journey. It can interpret legacy systems, extracting valuable insights and historical data that can help enrich the customer experience, and develop, deliver and better price product offerings. The data can also help create new and efficient customer service models, and facilitate better customer orchestration within the banking organization, as well as with peripheral partners.

      AI brings with it immense opportunities. It also comes with risks. From governance issues to potential bias in algorithms to data privacy, banks know they should balance these risks as they use AI if they want to build long-term, trust-based relationships with customers.

      Despite the uncertainty blanketing the banking sector, banks are cautiously optimistic on the future and are ready to leverage AI in new use cases to create a more personalised, enriched and long-term customer experience that supports customers through life events, and will keep them coming back time and time again

      Francisco Uria Fernandez

      Global Head Banking & Capital Markets

      KPMG International

      The insurance sector is at a crossroads. It can remain on its current path where it will likely continue to face declining consumer trust. Or, it can choose to venture along a new path, embracing technology and customer–centricity to evolve and maintain relevancy in a rapidly changing world.

      Much of the insurance industry, particularly general insurance, has become a commodity of sorts. Acting as such, insurers predominately compete on price, often at the expense of innovation and customer experience. The pandemic showed the weakness of this strategy.

      The use of complex terms and inconsistent claim payouts during the pandemic, led consumers to lose trust in insurers. Trust forms the basis of the Integrity pillar, which saw a 2 percent global decline in this year's CEE report. According to KPMG research, trust is a key factor in consumers recommending a company to others.

      MAIF has succeeded in retaining customer loyalty in 2023, ranking 4th overall for loyalty in France. The insurer – a standout in the industry – has been on a five–year journey to improve its customer experience, prioritizing their policyholders' well-being and satisfaction.

      Few others have done the same. In the pursuit to meet customers' needs for lower prices, many insurers cut costs to customer service. Customer satisfaction has taken a hit, especially during the claim process. The claim, which is essentially the tangible product insurers sell to its policyholders, is a critical touchpoint for customer trust and loyalty – all of which are made worse when the process does not consider the customer or their experience.

      The role of AI for insurers

      As insurers look ahead, trust should be a primary focus, alongside optimizing operations. As new regulations emerge, insurers can benefit from aligning their policies. In the UK, for example, more progressive firms are proactively aligning to the Consumer Day requirements, which is helping to rebuild customer trust and drive growth.

      Advanced technology can help support trust building. Data analytics has been long-used within the industry. Yet, insurers have done little to use their great amounts of customer data to create personalised products and experiences. The cloud can also help reduce operational costs and improve efficiency – which may soon become a necessity if insurers want to remain competitive and responsive as customers demand more agility and innovation.

      Artificial intelligence (AI), too, holds significant promise for insurers. Use cases can help cut costs from an operations standpoint. More significantly, insurers can come to see AI as a new colleague – a powerful one – that can enhance team capabilities around in terms of risk management, underwriting and pricing. With such an assistant on hand, insurers can enrich the customer experience at the signup stage, and more importantly from a customer perspective, at the claim stage.

      AI can also help insurers integrate their ESG values into their products – a regulatory requirement as well as a growing demand from increasingly socially conscious consumers.

      The future demands adaptability, customer-centricity and advanced technologies. By embracing these, insurers can meet the evolving needs of their customer and pave the way for a more resilient, relevant and innovative industry.

      There is a generation of innovation awaiting the insurance industry. For example, AI can help address specific challenges found in the claims process or underwriting. It can also be used to analyzed the already rich pool of data to create products which are more relevant to the emerging needs of customers and businesses. Furthermore, with challenges the industry faces in selecting increasingly high risks against a backdrop of climate change and instability, AI could be leveraged to reverse decline in risk appetites. With AI, the possibilities seem endless. To capture the opportunities ahead of them, insurers will need to see their role beyond a commodity, and rethink the link between customer experience and commercial value.

      James Henderson

      Customer Insurance Director

      KPMG in the UK

      The hotel sector is riding the wave of recovery. Driven by changing customer behaviors and technological advances, the sector has emerged from the pandemic as a beacon of resilience and adaptability.

      Like other sectors, the hotel recovery was challenged with labour shortages. Plus, faced with shifting traveler preferences, the industry has been industrious and creative in evolving to meet new demands and expectations.

      As a result, the overall travel and hotel industry saw a 3 percent decline in their global Customer Experience Excellence (CEE) score. Yet, 5 hotels stood out to customers, who ranked them among the top 10 in 3 markets. In Mexico, Marriott was ranked second and Hilton sits in sixth place. Hilton Hotels & Resorts was ranked in sixth place in the UK. In France, Mercure placed fourth, followed directly by Novotel in fifth after jumping 14 places over last year.

      Adding to this upswing is consumers' growing preference for memories over merchandise. Even with a cost-of-living crisis and uncertain economic times, consumers are prioritizing their spend on leisure activities. This includes domestic and international travel as well as other unique events.

      Rethinking hotel strategies for the future

      Out of this, a new trend has emerged: hoteliers are using their space to host fun, entertaining experiences for guests, such as escape rooms or themed evenings. This collective focus on leisure is a marked departure from the sector's reliance on business travel, which has been slower to bounce back in the era of Team meetings and remote work.

      The hotel boom has brought about operational challenges. The hotel shutdown during the pandemic saw an exodus of hotel workers, many of whom chose not to return when travel opened back up. This demanded hotels to rethink their staffing strategies, often leading to wage increases and innovative approaches to attract and retain talent.

      Travel marketplaces, such as booking.com, are also challenging the sector. Starting to use generative AI, these platforms help travelers plan their vacations, and in the process, are capturing deeper, broader customer insights that go well beyond what hoteliers can capture.

      In response to these challenges, hotels are embracing technology and redefining customer engagement. Hotels, like airlines, have used AI to dynamically price rooms. They are also expanding their loyalty programs across the full spectrum of their hotel brands to collect essential data to better understand their customers and help personalize experiences.

      Looking ahead, such personalised experiences will need to balance between technology-led services with those delivered by humans, tuning into the specific needs of travelers in specific situations. This attention to the customer, while harnessing the power of data and AI will enable hotels to enhance operational efficiency and customer satisfaction.

      Hotels will have to find the right formula that will integrate technology at the right points to enhance the customer experience. As they do, they'll need to consider the right balance between people-led and technology-led services to match customer needs as they change over the duration of their stay. This will be especially important as hybrid leisure and business stays increase in the post-pandemic world.

      Will Hawkley

      Global Head of Leisure and Hospitality

      KPMG in the UK

      The airlines industry is soaring into a new era. Coming out of the hardships of the pandemic, the sector has made a robust recovery and is on track to surpass pre-COVID levels in 2024. Now, the industry is focused on reinventing itself to meet the evolving demands of customer expectations.

      Emirates is one of the airlines leading the sector in exceeding customer expectations. Ranked the top brand in the UAE for the third year in a row, the airline carrier has also made significant gains in the UK, moving up the brand list to the number 11 spot, up from 92 last year.

      Personalisation, along with improved Time and Effort, are two key factors driving airline customers today. In the immediate aftermath of the pandemic, travelers were understanding, even forgiving, of flight delays, baggage mishaps and more. This is no longer the case. Travelers want seamless, contactless services akin to their experience in the e-commerce sector. In response, airlines are investing in technologies to enable digital interactions from check-in to in-flight services.

      Sustainable and loyal: A new focus

      Customer also want more efficient, environmentally conscious airlines. In response, many air carriers have made fairly bold aspirational targets in terms fuel efficient aircrafts, sustainable aviation fuels, and achieving net-zero carbon emissions from their operations by 2050. Yet, this is proving difficult to execute, especially with the high cost and low availability of Sustainable Aviation Fuels (SAF).

      In addition, supply chain disruptions are making it difficult to source and purchase new, efficient aircrafts. This is made worse as the world's few major manufacturers are still behind their pre-COVID production levels. While electrification is not a significant driver in the 2050 timeline to decarbonize aircraft flight operations, the initial focus will be on electrifying ground operations, including on ground aircrafts, baggage handling, shuttles and other support vehicles.

      Loyalty programs are another key strategy for airlines as they look ahead. With the availability of AI and advanced data analytics, airlines can make better use of their loyalty programs to capture detailed customer data and analyze it in ways that will allow them to more deeply understand their customers’ travel habits and preferences. All so they can better anticipate their needs and wants, and tailor services on the ground and in the air.

      Part of enhancing their loyalty program will be building on their already successful ecosystem of partners. Where today they are partnering with banks and local travel providers, in the future they may consider other partners who touch the customer in their overall travel journey.

      From taxis to airports, each part of the travel journey affects the customer experience. Gaining more control over this extended experience and creating a more cohesive experience will likely become the future for airlines. The challenge, of course, will be navigating the complexities of data sharing and partnership dynamics while making the most use of AI

      The airline industry is inherently physical – it requires moving people from point A to point B – so a fully digital experience isn't possible. The trick for airlines then is to integrate digital experiences at the right points and at the right times for its customers, without fully disconnecting the human touch. Offer a contactless check-in, while ensuring staff is available to provide support if and when needed to make the experience smooth for the customer.

      Malcom Ramsay

      Global Head of Aviation

      KPMG in Singapore

      Coming soon

      The future of telco is upon us. As technologies are advancing, market dynamics are shifting, competition is heating up and customer expectations are intensifying, telco companies are having to rethink and reimagine their business and operating models.

      Overall, the telco industry saw a 3 percent decline in their CEE scores in 2023 versus the previous year. With the exception of Value, the sector saw a drop across The Six Pillars. Further, of the 129 telco brands included in the study, only 4 were ranked among any of the 21 countries' top 10.

      The faltering comes partly off the back of the massive investments in 5G infrastructure telcos have made in recent years to meet the surge in customers' broadband demands. With such high costs to recover, margins are being squeezed like never before, despite high consumer revenues.

      With little wiggle room, consumers and commercial clients are demanding their telco companies do better. They want more flexible service, greater billing transparency and enhanced ease of use. A recent KPMG survey of US consumers revealed that 41% of respondents desire lower costs for the same service, further pressuring telcos to balance pricing with value delivery.1

      Making matters worse, traditional business models rooted in providing connectivity services like voice and data are being challenged by hyperscalers – companies like Microsoft, Google or Amazon that offer similar connectivity services – which could crowd out telcos if they decide to build their own private networks. With larger budgets and more ambitious agendas, these new entrants are creating a competitive urgency across the industry.

      From telco to techco

      There is good news: telco companies own extensive infrastructure and a wealth of customer data. For example, telco players can bundle their network access with data-driven solutions that encompass content and data connectivity. The first step toward such a pursuit would require telcos to evolve their organisations to become more like technology companies, forging strategic alliances with hyperscalers as they try to move away from their traditional branding as network infrastructure providers. They are leaning into that claim by launching new products and services that help them move up the technology stack.

      Advanced technologies can help alleviate the demands for massive infrastructure investments. More broadly, AI can help evolve the industry. While the role of AI is still unfolding, it can be first used to enhance network operations and 5G capabilities, while providing smarter, more connected ecosystems. For fixed and pay-TV markets, Personalisation and content optimization can also benefit from AI.

      Telcos will need to navigate AI carefully, considering data protection, privacy and cybersecurity. This way they can harness AI's potential without compromising customer trust or security. They will also want to elevate the customer experience, adeptly meeting client needs in the moment with innovative products and tailored service delivery.

      The rollout of 5G and, eventually, 6G will open up a range of new applications and Web 3.0 technologies. To make the most of it, telcos will need to figure out how they can leverage their massive pools of data to enhance the customer experience and build out solutions, content and connected data that can transform them into the techcos they want to become.

      Mark Gibson

      Global Head of Technology, Media & Telecoms

      KPMG International

      Latest insights

      Tracking the changing nature of consumer buying behaviour to understand what matters to them most.

      Tech: A bold sector that innovates while leading by example

      Latest insights

      Align your business around your customers to help create a seamless, agile, digitally enabled organization that can deliver leading experiences and new levels of performance and value.

      KPMG firms' suite of services to help transform their back-office functions, leveraging target operating models that are designed with the future in mind.

      Our Trust Imperative brings together risk and regulatory services that build trust and confidence in the organization and its digital transformation journey. It helps ensure that businesses can navigate risk and regulation with greater predictability – and deliver on the promise to keep customer data trusted, safe and reliable.

      KPMG firms' suite of services to help transform their back-office functions, leveraging target operating models that are designed with the future in mind.

      Queries? Get in touch with our Customer Experience team

      Owen Lewis

      Partner, Head of AI & Velocity, Head of Banking & Capital Markets, Global Lead for Financial Services Cost Transformation

      KPMG in Ireland

      Placing customers at the heart of your business to drive commercial value