Indonesian Tax Amnesty – Will it affect Singapore property prices?
Indonesian Tax Amnesty
The article was published in the The Edge magazine.
Indonesia has seen a trend of rising fiscal deficit, culminating in a record budget deficit in 2015. The resource-rich nation’s coffer was affected by low global demand and weakening commodity prices for essential exports such as coal and crude palm oil.
The sluggish global economic growth and moderated growth faced by China, a key trading partner of Indonesia, certainly did not help. In a bid to improve its budget position, the Indonesian government has proposed a plan for a tax amnesty, aimed at encouraging wealthy citizens to bring back their offshore wealth.
How does it work?
The Indonesian tax amnesty provides some reprieve to wealthy Indonesians who have been remiss in their tax affairs to take advantage of this opportunity to disclose and optionally repatriate their undeclared assets and pay only a modest clearance levy on the assets declared.
The levy is applicable on net assets, calculated by deducting directly related liabilities, up to prescribed percentages from the cash or market value of assets being declared. The clearance levy rate varies, depending on the timing of the filing and whether the offshore assets are repatriated to Indonesia by a stipulated timeline.
|Clearance levy rates
|Period within which tax amnesty declaration is filed||Onshore assets declared and Offshore assets declared & repatriated||Offshore assets declared but not repatriated|
|1 July 2016 - 30 September 2016||2% (if repatriated by 31 December 2016)||4%|
|1 October 2016 - 31 December 2016||3% (if repatriated by 31 December 2016)||6%|
|1 January 2017 - 31 March 2017||5% (if repatriated by 31 March 2017)||10%|
Both individuals and companies including those without a tax identification number can avail themselves of the tax amnesty. However, existing tax defaulters who are currently being investigated, undergoing judicial proceedings or have been charged with tax crimes are excluded from the tax amnesty program.
This is a golden opportunity for errant Indonesians to set their tax record straight and at the same time, absolve themselves of adverse consequences (such as tax audits and investigations) arising from historical undeclared wealth. The tax amnesty also provides some level of assurance, as the Indonesian authorities have undertaken not to share information collected through the amnesty exercise with other parties. They will also not use it as a basis for instituting any criminal proceedings against the taxpayer.
However, there are compromises to be made by the taxpayer as he has to give up any outstanding tax refund claims from the authorities, forfeit unutilised tax losses and withdraw existing disputes with the tax authorities.
Where does the money go?
The proceeds from the amnesty program have been earmarked for beefing up infrastructure and other sectors which the Indonesian government has chosen to focus on. Monies repatriated to Indonesia have to be kept in Indonesia for at least three years and may only be invested based on a stipulated list of permissible investments. This list includes real estate, REITs, infrastructure projects, government securities, private company bonds, gold, marketable securities and banking products.
To participate or not?
There are harsh consequences such as penalties and sanctions that may be imposed on under-declared or undeclared assets. For those deliberating whether to participate, another factor for consideration is there are global initiatives for greater tax transparency which are being implemented by various countries as we speak. For example, Singapore will be embracing the OECD’s automatic exchange of information framework in 2018 and could agree to exchange taxpayer information with other countries such as Indonesia, subject to certain conditions.
Will this have an impact on Singapore property?
Indonesians have historically been keen investors in Singapore property and account for a significant proportion of foreign purchases of property in Singapore. The stability and transparency of the Singapore property market coupled with factors like cheaper credit, ease of purchase and relatively strong rental demand have convinced many wealthy Indonesians to purchase Singapore properties, typically prime luxury properties in Districts 9, 10 and 11.
This recent tax amnesty offer from the Indonesian Government leads one to wonder whether there might be a resultant short term impact on prime residential properties in Singapore as Indonesians deliberate whether to liquidate their property holdings in Singapore to take advantage of this one-off golden offer.
A few factors that may have an impact on the decision making process:
- As shown above, Indonesians have up to 30 September 2016 to enjoy the lowest levy bracket which means the clock is ticking
- Repatriated funds are allowed to be invested in Indonesian real estate (with certain exceptions)
- Offshore investments (including properties) may have to be disposed to fund the clearance levy payment
- The Singapore Dollar has strengthened considerably against the Indonesian Rupiah since 2010
- There has been strong growth in residential property prices in Indonesia since 2008
Given current slow market conditions in Singapore, will these factors provide the impetus for an urgent sale of properties in Singapore at lower prices? It’s anybody’s guess but we do note a number of prime properties owned by Indonesians that are available for sale at asking prices that are less than the valuation or purchase price.
Perhaps it’s time for bargain property hunters to sit up and take notice.
The article was contributed by Tay Hong Beng, Head of Real Estate, and Alan Lau, Head of Financial Services Tax, at KPMG in Singapore. The views expressed are their own.